Italy player ratings for every match we cover, kept on one page. The newest ratings sit at the top. Below them, the season table averages each Italy player's marks out of 10 across every match we have rated, and every write-up is linked so you can read why each mark was given.
Latest Italy player ratings
Pick a match to read every mark out of 10 and the reason behind it.
15 Nov 2026 · v Argentina
Italy Player Ratings vs Argentina: Zuliani 8.5, ‘We Could Have Won It’
Manuel Zuliani Openside flanker“Player of the match. Five turnovers, two of them in the first 16 minutes to stop Argentina in the Italy 22, plus 19 tackles and…”8.5
Monty Ioane Left wing“Scored the try and made 98 metres from 13 carries, nearly three times as many as anyone in an Argentina shirt.”8- Ross Vintcent Blindside flanker“Made 22 tackles, the most on the pitch, won three lineouts and stole the ball at an Argentina maul early in the second half.”7.5
Italy player ratings 2026: season averages
Every player's average mark out of 10 across the 1 Italy match we have rated in 2026, highest first. Replacements count when we rated them.
- 1
Manuel Zuliani8.5 - 2
Monty Ioane8.0 - 3
Leonardo Marin7.5 - 4
Lorenzo Cannone7.5 - 5Ross Vintcent7.5
- 6
Danilo Fischetti7.0 - 7
Simone Ferrari7.0 - 8
Stephen Varney7.0 - 9
Federico Ruzza6.5 - 10
Gianmarco Lucchesi6.5
Italy player ratings 2026: questions answered
Italy season averages 2026: top 10 as a table
| Rank | Player | Matches rated | Average /10 | Best mark |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Manuel Zuliani | 1 | 8.5 | 8.5 v Argentina |
| 2 | Monty Ioane | 1 | 8 | 8 v Argentina |
| 3 | Leonardo Marin | 1 | 7.5 | 7.5 v Argentina |
| 4 | Lorenzo Cannone | 1 | 7.5 | 7.5 v Argentina |
| 5 | Ross Vintcent | 1 | 7.5 | 7.5 v Argentina |
| 6 | Danilo Fischetti | 1 | 7 | 7 v Argentina |
| 7 | Simone Ferrari | 1 | 7 | 7 v Argentina |
| 8 | Stephen Varney | 1 | 7 | 7 v Argentina |
| 9 | Federico Ruzza | 1 | 6.5 | 6.5 v Argentina |
| 10 | Gianmarco Lucchesi | 1 | 6.5 | 6.5 v Argentina |
Who is the best Italy player of 2026 on our ratings?
Manuel Zuliani tops our 2026 table on 8.5 out of 10 from 1 match (v Argentina).
What is the highest single Italy rating of 2026?
8.5 out of 10, given to Manuel Zuliani v Argentina.
Show all 20 players
- 11
Niccolò Cannone6.5 - 12
Tommaso Allan6.5 - 13
Ange Capuozzo6.0 - 14
Federico Mori6.0 - 15
Marco Riccioni6.0 - 16
Muhamed Hasa6.0 - 17
Giacomo Nicotera5.5 - 18
Paolo Garbisi5.5 - 19
Paolo Odogwu5.5 - 20
Enoch Opoku-Gyamfi5.0
Every player at a glance · 15 Nov 2026
Italy v Argentina
Italy Player Ratings vs Argentina: Zuliani 8.5, ‘We Could Have Won It’
- Team average
- 6.6
- Players rated
- 20
Forwards
17Danilo FischettiLoosehead prop
25.5Giacomo NicoteraHooker
37Simone FerrariTighthead prop
46.5Niccolò CannoneLock
56.5Federico RuzzaLock- 67.5Ross VintcentBlindside flanker
78.5Manuel ZulianiOpenside flanker
87.5Lorenzo CannoneNumber 8
Backs
97Stephen VarneyScrum-half
105.5Paolo GarbisiFly-half
118Monty IoaneLeft wing
127.5Leonardo MarinInside centre
135.5Paolo OdogwuOutside centre
146Ange CapuozzoRight wing
156.5Tommaso AllanFull-back
Replacements
166.5Gianmarco LucchesiReplacement
176Muhamed HasaReplacement
186Marco RiccioniReplacement
195Enoch Opoku-GyamfiReplacement
236Federico MoriReplacement
How we rate Italy players
Each player gets a mark out of 10 after every match we cover, based on what they did with and without the ball: carries, tackles, set piece, kicking, errors and penalties. Every mark comes with a short reason in the match write-up. A 10 is rare and means a match nobody could have played better.
- 8 outstanding
- 7 good
- 5.5 mixed
- 4 poor
