Skip to content

Springboks lineout offside went unpunished twice, says McKenzie

Springboks lineout offside went unpunished twice in their 21-19 defeat to France, according to former Wallabies head coach Ewen McKenzie.

France players celebrate at the end of their 21-19 win over the Springboks at the Stade de France as South Africa players look on.
Photo: Reuters

Ewen McKenzie wrote “Offside in attack” in his notes the first time the Springboks threw over the back of the lineout in their 21-19 defeat to France.

On Rugby Unity, McKenzie said the Springboks used that long lineout throw three times in Paris and “got away with it” twice.

They were “penalised… once, and that was the time they scored the try”, he said.

Should the officials have stopped it at the first throw? Tell us in the comments.

READ MORE: Ewen McKenzie says the Springboks were ‘so honest’ in their kick chase in Paris

McKenzie flagged the Springboks lineout offside from the first throw

McKenzie said: “…The very first time, early in the game, South Africa threw over the back of the lineout. I wrote on my notes, ‘Offside in attack.'”

“And sure enough, later on when they scored the try, it got taken back,” he added.

It had to be sorted out at the start of the game, he said. In his view South Africa had already got away with it once, and the TMO could have said something then.

READ MORE: Rassie Erasmus admits the Springboks got it wrong by chasing scrum penalties in Paris

“For those that don’t know the law: you can’t go into the 10-metre space until the ball’s crossed the 15-metre line… So it was obvious on the first one,” McKenzie said.

McKenzie said the Springboks used the throw again in the second half, and nothing was done.

France led 21-7 at half-time. The Springboks won the second half 12-0 with 14 men, after Jasper Wiese’s 43rd-minute red card, and finished two points short.

Benjamin Kayser says the Springboks were hard done by when referee Andrea Piardi went back on a yellow-card warning.

Only pulled up when they scored, says McKenzie

“So that’s the consistency I struggle with. They disallowed the try because it was a try, but the other two times they threw it, they got away with it,” McKenzie said.

“So what’s South Africa to do? I’m not blaming South Africa…” he added.

Will the long throw get pulled up in Dublin? South Africa play Ireland there on Saturday 21 November.

Ireland have won three of the last five meetings between the two sides.

READ MORE: Ireland v South Africa: every result from the last five meetings before Dublin

THE NORTH DOMINATES! Wales beat New Zealand & France trump Springboks: Steve Hansen reacts!Video · plays from YouTube
Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Siya Kolisi carries the ball into a French tackle with Pieter-Steph du Toit in support
Next up

Kevin Putt: Springboks ‘Were Terrible’ Against France In Paris

Kevin Putt played scrum-half for the Springboks, and he says they "were terrible on the day" in Paris. Now his family in Ireland "see a little bit of a weakness"…

South Africa · 3 min read

More on South Africa

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?