Skip to content

‘His eyes are watering’: Muliaina on McCaw and Zac Guildford

Mils Muliaina has described a private meeting in 2011 in which All Blacks captain Richie McCaw tore into a young Zac Guildford, with Muliaina and Keven Mealamu in the room.

Richie McCaw shouting and pointing to direct play in the All Blacks' black kit.

Mils Muliaina has revealed that Richie McCaw tore into a young Zac Guildford in a private meeting with senior All Blacks in 2011, describing a captain who left his team-mate’s eyes watering.

“Richie is just giving it to him… his eyes are watering,” the former fullback told the Between Two Beers podcast. It happened after the All Blacks lost in Brisbane earlier in 2011, he said.

Muliaina recalls McCaw asking Guildford who he thought he was. With hooker Keven Mealamu also in the room, Muliaina says he put his “father hat” on.

Was McCaw right to go that hard at a young team-mate? Tell us in the comments.

Gilbert Enoka’s text put Zac Guildford in the middle

The call came from Gilbert Enoka, the All Blacks’ mental skills coach, known in the squad as Bert.

“We lost in Brisbane and I get a text from Bert that we got to come in… Kevy and me and Richie in the room, and here’s Zachie in the middle,” Muliaina said.

READ MORE: Gilbert Enoka names the three All Blacks who defined an era

Mils Muliaina and Richie McCaw in All Blacks kit; both were in the room with Zac Guildford in 2011.

Why Muliaina put his ‘father hat’ on

“I kind of put my father hat on, cuz you kind of like, he’s this kid, mate, and I kind of put myself in his shoes, cuz I stuff up all the time,” he said.

He means it. On the same podcast he describes making the front page of the Herald at 19, and being named in his first All Blacks squad with a broken eye socket after a night out.

“At some stage you got to… sit back and go, man… you make mistakes, he’s human,” he said. “He’s not a god. Richie probably doesn’t make those mistakes.”

Mealamu played it down

The former All Black was glad Mealamu was there. “Luckily… he’s awesome, cuz he’s your sort of guy that sort of plays things down and real supportive,” he said.

Muliaina came through the grades with McCaw

Muliaina has known McCaw since they were young players in the South Island.

“I came through the grades with Richie,” he said. “He was always a tough player, but he worked really hard. And he was often behind someone else. He wasn’t your normal starting sort of seven, but he was a hard worker.”

Muliaina remembers a line McCaw always used. “Richie had always said, you know, you want to be absolutely playing your worst game but still win by 20.”

Keven Mealamu in All Blacks kit.

Muliaina says support is what gets a player back

He says he looks at it from one angle. “The best thing you can try and do is support them to try and get them back out of that,” he said.

READ MORE: Kieran Read reveals Crusaders stars were told ‘you boys need to rest’ before the 2011 World Cup

Mils Muliaina Breaks His Silence on UK Arrest & Reflects on 100 All Black TestsVideo · plays from YouTube

Watch the full interview on Between Two Beers. Mils Muliaina was speaking to hosts Steve and Seamus in an episode published on 15 November 2026.

Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Mils Muliaina, 100 Tests for the All Blacks, talks about Beauden Barrett on The Breakdown on Sky Sport NZ
Next up

Mils Muliaina Says Beauden Barrett Never Deserved The Heat

Beauden Barrett scored twice in Sydney and Mils Muliaina says he never deserved the heat. Brad Weber shows the first-receiver swap behind Moorby's try.

Australia · 6 min read

More on New Zealand

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?