Scotland player ratings for every match we cover, kept on one page. The newest ratings sit at the top. Below them, the season table averages each Scotland player's marks out of 10 across every match we have rated, and every write-up is linked so you can read why each mark was given.
Latest Scotland player ratings
Pick a match to read every mark out of 10 and the reason behind it.
21 Nov 2026 · v Japan
Scotland player ratings v Japan: Graham and McConnell hit 9.5
Liam McConnell Blindside flanker“Three tries on his third cap, the first of his Test career, from the flank.”9.5
Darcy Graham Right wing“A hat-trick, the 5th, 30th and 78th minutes.”9.5
Ollie Smith Full-back“Two tries, 119 metres from 15 carries and four line breaks.”9
Earlier Scotland ratings
Scotland player ratings 2026: season averages
Every player's average mark out of 10 across the 2 Scotland matches we have rated in 2026, highest first. Replacements count when we rated them.
- 1
Liam McConnell9.5 - 2
Ollie Smith9.0 - 3
Rory Darge8.5 - 4
Darcy Graham8.3 - 5
Jonny Gray8.0 - 6
Rory Hutchinson8.0 - 7
Matt Fagerson7.8 - 8
Ewan Ashman7.5 - 9
George Horne7.5 - 10
Kyle Rowe7.5
Scotland player ratings 2026: questions answered
Scotland season averages 2026: top 10 as a table
| Rank | Player | Matches rated | Average /10 | Best mark |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Liam McConnell | 1 | 9.5 | 9.5 v Japan |
| 2 | Ollie Smith | 1 | 9 | 9 v Japan |
| 3 | Rory Darge | 1 | 8.5 | 8.5 v Australia |
| 4 | Darcy Graham | 2 | 8.3 | 9.5 v Japan |
| 5 | Jonny Gray | 1 | 8 | 8 v Japan |
| 6 | Rory Hutchinson | 1 | 8 | 8 v Japan |
| 7 | Matt Fagerson | 2 | 7.8 | 8 v Japan |
| 8 | Ewan Ashman | 1 | 7.5 | 7.5 v Australia |
| 9 | George Horne | 1 | 7.5 | 7.5 v Japan |
| 10 | Kyle Rowe | 1 | 7.5 | 7.5 v Japan |
Who is the best Scotland player of 2026 on our ratings?
Darcy Graham has the best average among players rated in at least 2 matches: 8.3 out of 10 across 2 matches (best 9.5 v Japan). Liam McConnell tops the overall table on 9.5 from 1 match.
How many Scotland matches have we rated in 2026?
2 matches so far. Every rating links to its match write-up above.
What is the highest single Scotland rating of 2026?
9.5 out of 10, given to Liam McConnell v Japan, Darcy Graham v Japan.
Which Scotland player has been rated in the most matches?
Darcy Graham, rated in 2 matches with an average of 8.3 out of 10.
Show all 32 players
- 11
Seb Stephen7.5 - 12
Jamie Dobie7.3 - 13
Tom Jordan7.3 - 14
Max Williamson7.0 - 15
Jack Dempsey7.0 - 16
Ollie Leatherbarrow7.0 - 17
Gregor Brown6.8 - 18
Blair Kinghorn6.5 - 19
Gregor Hiddleston6.5 - 20
Ben White6.5 - 21
Josh Bayliss6.5 - 22
Magnus Bradbury6.5 - 23
Stafford McDowall6.5 - 24
Rory Sutherland6.0 - 25
Will Hurd6.0 - 26
Zander Fagerson6.0 - 27
Kyle Steyn6.0 - 28
Nathan McBeth6.0 - 29
Pierre Schoeman6.0 - 30
Finn Russell5.5 - 31
Freddy Douglas5.5 - 32
Huw Jones5.5
Every player at a glance · 21 Nov 2026
Scotland v Japan
Scotland player ratings v Japan: Graham and McConnell hit 9.5
- Team average
- 7.3
- Players rated
- 23
Forwards
16Nathan McBethLoosehead prop
27Gregor HiddlestonHooker
37Zander FagersonTighthead prop
48Jonny GrayLock
57Max WilliamsonLock
69.5Liam McConnellBlindside flanker
77Ollie LeatherbarrowOpenside flanker
88Matt FagersonNumber 8
Backs
98.5Jamie DobieScrum-half
107Tom JordanFly-half
117.5Kyle RoweLeft wing
128Rory HutchinsonInside centre
136.5Stafford McDowallOutside centre
149.5Darcy GrahamRight wing
159Ollie SmithFull-back
Replacements
167.5Seb StephenReplacement
176.5Rory SutherlandReplacement
186Will HurdReplacement
197Gregor BrownReplacement
206.5Magnus BradburyReplacement
215.5Freddy DouglasReplacement
227.5George HorneReplacement
236.5Blair KinghornReplacement
How we rate Scotland players
Each player gets a mark out of 10 after every match we cover, based on what they did with and without the ball: carries, tackles, set piece, kicking, errors and penalties. Every mark comes with a short reason in the match write-up. A 10 is rare and means a match nobody could have played better.
- 8 outstanding
- 7 good
- 5.5 mixed
- 4 poor

