Skip to content

Scotland Player Ratings: Every Rugby Test Rated

Last updated

Scotland player ratings for every match we cover, kept on one page. The newest ratings sit at the top. Below them, the season table averages each Scotland player's marks out of 10 across every match we have rated, and every write-up is linked so you can read why each mark was given.

Latest Scotland player ratings

Pick a match to read every mark out of 10 and the reason behind it.

Earlier Scotland ratings

Scotland player ratings 2026: season averages

Every player's average mark out of 10 across the 2 Scotland matches we have rated in 2026, highest first. Replacements count when we rated them.

  1. 1Liam McConnellLiam McConnell1 match · best 9.5 v Japan9.5
  2. 2Ollie SmithOllie Smith1 match · best 9 v Japan9.0
  3. 3Rory DargeRory Darge1 match · best 8.5 v Australia8.5
  4. 4Darcy GrahamDarcy Graham2 matches · best 9.5 v Japan8.3
  5. 5Jonny GrayJonny Gray1 match · best 8 v Japan8.0
  6. 6Rory HutchinsonRory Hutchinson1 match · best 8 v Japan8.0
  7. 7Matt FagersonMatt Fagerson2 matches · best 8 v Japan7.8
  8. 8Ewan AshmanEwan Ashman1 match · best 7.5 v Australia7.5
  9. 9George HorneGeorge Horne1 match · best 7.5 v Japan7.5
  10. 10Kyle RoweKyle Rowe1 match · best 7.5 v Japan7.5

Scotland player ratings 2026: questions answered

Scotland season averages 2026: top 10 as a table
RankPlayerMatches ratedAverage /10Best mark
1Liam McConnell19.59.5 v Japan
2Ollie Smith199 v Japan
3Rory Darge18.58.5 v Australia
4Darcy Graham28.39.5 v Japan
5Jonny Gray188 v Japan
6Rory Hutchinson188 v Japan
7Matt Fagerson27.88 v Japan
8Ewan Ashman17.57.5 v Australia
9George Horne17.57.5 v Japan
10Kyle Rowe17.57.5 v Japan

Who is the best Scotland player of 2026 on our ratings?

Darcy Graham has the best average among players rated in at least 2 matches: 8.3 out of 10 across 2 matches (best 9.5 v Japan). Liam McConnell tops the overall table on 9.5 from 1 match.

How many Scotland matches have we rated in 2026?

2 matches so far. Every rating links to its match write-up above.

What is the highest single Scotland rating of 2026?

9.5 out of 10, given to Liam McConnell v Japan, Darcy Graham v Japan.

Which Scotland player has been rated in the most matches?

Darcy Graham, rated in 2 matches with an average of 8.3 out of 10.

Show all 32 players
  1. 11Seb StephenSeb Stephen1 match · best 7.5 v Japan7.5
  2. 12Jamie DobieJamie Dobie2 matches · best 8.5 v Japan7.3
  3. 13Tom JordanTom Jordan2 matches · best 7.5 v Australia7.3
  4. 14Max WilliamsonMax Williamson2 matches · best 7 v Japan7.0
  5. 15Jack DempseyJack Dempsey1 match · best 7 v Australia7.0
  6. 16Ollie LeatherbarrowOllie Leatherbarrow1 match · best 7 v Japan7.0
  7. 17Gregor BrownGregor Brown2 matches · best 7 v Japan6.8
  8. 18Blair KinghornBlair Kinghorn2 matches · best 6.5 v Japan6.5
  9. 19Gregor HiddlestonGregor Hiddleston2 matches · best 7 v Japan6.5
  10. 20Ben WhiteBen White1 match · best 6.5 v Australia6.5
  11. 21Josh BaylissJosh Bayliss1 match · best 6.5 v Australia6.5
  12. 22Magnus BradburyMagnus Bradbury1 match · best 6.5 v Japan6.5
  13. 23Stafford McDowallStafford McDowall1 match · best 6.5 v Japan6.5
  14. 24Rory SutherlandRory Sutherland2 matches · best 6.5 v Japan6.0
  15. 25Will HurdWill Hurd2 matches · best 6 v Japan6.0
  16. 26Zander FagersonZander Fagerson2 matches · best 7 v Japan6.0
  17. 27Kyle SteynKyle Steyn1 match · best 6 v Australia6.0
  18. 28Nathan McBethNathan McBeth1 match · best 6 v Japan6.0
  19. 29Pierre SchoemanPierre Schoeman1 match · best 6 v Australia6.0
  20. 30Finn RussellFinn Russell1 match · best 5.5 v Australia5.5
  21. 31Freddy DouglasFreddy Douglas1 match · best 5.5 v Japan5.5
  22. 32Huw JonesHuw Jones1 match · best 5.5 v Australia5.5

Every player at a glance · 21 Nov 2026

Scotland v Japan

Scotland player ratings v Japan: Graham and McConnell hit 9.5

Team average
7.3
Players rated
23

Forwards

Backs

Replacements

Read the reason for every mark

How we rate Scotland players

Each player gets a mark out of 10 after every match we cover, based on what they did with and without the ball: carries, tackles, set piece, kicking, errors and penalties. Every mark comes with a short reason in the match write-up. A 10 is rare and means a match nobody could have played better.

  • 8 outstanding
  • 7 good
  • 5.5 mixed
  • 4 poor