Ben Youngs, the former England scrum-half, says Antoine Dupont has three kicks that no other nine can match. “I don’t think another nine can actually do all three of those kicks,” he told the Aotearoa Rugby Pod.
Youngs named them: a 50-22 off the left foot, a grubber off the right and a crossfield kick. A 50-22 is a kick from your own half that bounces out in the opposition 22, and your side get the throw-in. A grubber is a low kick along the ground.
Dupont, Roigard or Lucu: who is the best nine in the world? Tell us in the comments.
READ MORE: Dan Biggar and Richie Mo’unga on the All Blacks after Wales
Why does Ben Youngs rate Antoine Dupont above Cam Roigard?
A host asked what Cam Roigard needs to reach Dupont’s level. Youngs said he is “a big Roigard fan” and “a serious player”. On kicking, though, Roigard “just falls a little bit short of the others”.
In France, Youngs said, “the nines are the heartbeat of the team”. He sees New Zealand now running a lot of their play through Roigard, which he called “more of a traditional sort of French way of playing”.
“I don’t think another nine can do it off both feet like he did,” Youngs said. What Youngs does not see in the other nines is “the other side of the ball that he brings as well”.
What does Dupont do without the ball?
Jackalling means winning the ball back at the tackle. Youngs says Dupont does that, and more.
“Who jumps the ball at the end? Dupont. Who’s jackalling? Dupont. Who’s holding guys up? Dupont.”
People think of nines “more as attacking guys rather than the defensive players”, he said.
How does Maxime Lucu fit into the debate?
Youngs also rates Maxime Lucu as “a bit of the all-court game”, with a strong kicking game and a great passing game. He recalled a Toulouse v Bordeaux European Cup quarter-final. Lucu “made about 16 tackles and they got two turnovers in jackal”, he said.
A host said Lucu has never played a Test in the southern hemisphere. Youngs gave some context. “The Top 14 is an absolute slog,” he said. The French season starts almost at the end of August and can run to the end of June or the start of July, he said. Some French players missed the tour because they were still in the Top 14 final rounds.
“Let the southern hemisphere come to him, mate, and he’ll show you what he’s all about.”
Has Dupont answered the ACL question?
Roigard has come back from “a really nasty knee injury”, Youngs said. Dupont “has done his ACL twice”.
Many people wondered whether Dupont would return as the same player, Youngs said. There were “a lot of question marks”. Youngs said he is delighted for “someone that has answered that”.
He was speaking in the week England face New Zealand at Allianz Stadium, Twickenham, at 2.10pm GMT on Saturday 21 November.
READ MORE: Wales 35-28 New Zealand: match report









Comments
No one has weighed in yet.
Be the first - what did you make of it?