Former England scrum-half Ben Youngs has demanded a public apology from Springboks prop Trevor Nyakane over Antoine Dupont, and claimed Rassie Erasmus “got out-Rassied” by Fabien Galthié in Paris.
Youngs made the claims on the For The Love Of Rugby podcast, where he reviewed the game with his former England team-mate Dan Cole. Nyakane co-hosts the South African edition of the show with Steven Kitshoff.
France beat South Africa 21-19 at the Stade de France on 13 November. Dupont made his first Test start at fly-half, with Maxime Lucu at nine, in a game with five cards, including a red card for Jasper Wiese (France v South Africa match report).
READ MORE: Rassie Erasmus: ‘Just human’ for ref to stop penalising
‘This Ben guy’
The row started before the Test. In a combined team of the week, Nyakane and Kitshoff picked Springboks scrum-half Morné van den Berg. Youngs and Cole picked Dupont.
Nyakane blamed “this Ben guy”. “He likes Dupont quite a bit,” he said, and added that there had been a time when he would have picked Lucu as the best nine.
When Kitshoff read out a viewer’s Facebook comment that called the pickers muppets, Nyakane stood by Van den Berg. “I’m still sticking with that one actually,” he said, before calling Youngs and Cole “the two muppets”.
‘A public apology’
The 37-year-old replied on his own show two days after the Paris Test.
“If Trev can’t see and can’t, he can’t accept that Dupont is the best nine in the world, arguably the best player in the world, I don’t know what game Trev’s watching unless he can just accept it now,” he said.
“He’s just got to accept it. I don’t know whether he’s now just sticking to his guns and therefore he’s gone so far down a rabbit hole of like ‘no, no, no’ that he can’t.
“So the second thing I want is a public apology because Dupont was remarkable and Rassie got out-Rassied. Galthié did an absolute number on him.”
Ben Youngs: ‘Too late, Rassie’
Youngs admitted the team sheet had fooled him. “I fell for it. We all fell for it,” he said, before adding: “Galthié had a blinder. He out-Rassied Rassie.
“Rassie maybe watched the warm-up, Coley. This is what I think happened. He watched the French warm-up and he thought, ‘hang on a minute’.”
In Youngs’s version, Erasmus saw that Dupont had “got ten on the back, but he’s running as nine in the warm-up”, and changed his front row because he was “not going to allow Galthié to get one-nil up on me”.
“Too late, Rassie, you got done,” Youngs added.
The warm-up story is Youngs’s guess. In fact, South Africa replaced their whole front row after 35 minutes, with France 21-7 ahead.
Youngs singled out Dupont’s kicking. “Coley, there is not another nine on this planet that can do just the three kicks alone,” he said, listing two cross-field kicks and a grubber for Louis Bielle-Biarrey. “Those three kicks alone, there isn’t another. All off different feet.”
Cole agreed. “This team goes with Dupont and goes as far as Dupont will take them,” he said. On his tackling, he added: “I don’t think there’s many better than Antoine Dupont.”
And on the final minutes: “Who’s the bloke diving on the loose ball? Antoine Dupont. 80th minute of the game, Test match.”
Youngs then went back to Nyakane. “Basically what we’re getting at here is Trev, you need to publicly apologise,” he said. “You really got this one wrong, big fella.”
South Africa now turn to Dublin, where they face Ireland on Saturday 21 November.

READ MORE: Rassie Erasmus: Dublin not ‘a happy hunting ground’ for me




Comments
No one has weighed in yet.
Be the first - what did you make of it?