Skip to content
News

Rassie Erasmus Predicts ‘Technicality’ Will Let Prendergast Play

Rassie Erasmus expects a 'technicality' to let Sam Prendergast face the Springboks despite his hip-drop citing. Should the Ireland 10 be banned?

Sam Prendergast in action for Ireland

Rassie Erasmus expects Sam Prendergast to face the Springboks on Saturday, even though the Ireland fly-half has been cited for an alleged hip-drop tackle. “We are in the Northern Hemisphere,” Erasmus said in Dublin on Monday. “I think there is going to be a technicality and he is going to play.”

Prendergast is the first player cited for a hip-drop since World Rugby outlawed the tackle at the start of the November window. The challenge on Fiji captain Peceli Yato came in the 23rd minute of Ireland’s 43–15 win at the Aviva Stadium on Saturday, and it went unpunished on the day.

Erasmus called the tackle “terrible”. “We all thought it’s an immediate red card,” he said, because it was exactly what coaches had been shown as a hip-drop at a World Rugby meeting.

Should Sam Prendergast miss the Springboks Test? Tell us in the comments.

Where the Prendergast citing stands

The citing was reported by RTÉ and the Irish Times on Monday. The Nations Championship had not confirmed it publicly by Monday evening.

The competition is running an expedited disciplinary process. Prendergast can accept the charge and take a sanction straight away. If Ireland contest it, the case goes to an independent hearing later this week. No outcome had been announced when this article was published.

Yato scored a try moments after the tackle, then went off with an ankle injury and was in a protective boot after the game.

If Prendergast is banned, Ciarán Frawley is in line to start at 10, and Ulster’s Jamie Benson could win a first cap off the bench. Andy Farrell names his side on Thursday. How Prendergast played before the tackle is in our Ireland player ratings v Fiji.

Why Rassie Erasmus thinks Prendergast will play

Erasmus said the coaches spent about three hours on the hip-drop at that World Rugby meeting, with the examples shown “over and over”. The Irish and French coaches, he said, were not there. He could not understand how a TMO could watch Saturday’s tackle and see nothing wrong, and asked how Fiji coach Jake White must have felt watching his player go off injured.

He admitted he was “not 100% sure how it works” and was “not a legal guy”. He also questioned the process, asking whether the citing had landed inside the 12-hour window and who had brought it.

The rest came from experience. “I don’t have a pleasant experience here,” he said, naming Lood de Jager, Jan-Hendrik Wessels and Franco Mostert. In his telling, those cases never seem to go South Africa’s way.

He also brought up Tadhg Furlong. An independent committee cleared the Ireland prop of an alleged groin grab on Gavin Coombes in a Leinster v Munster game last month. Wessels, Erasmus said, got nine weeks for what he saw as the same thing. From a South African point of view, he said, “that hurt”.

“I’m not saying anybody’s doing anything wrong,” he added. “My gut feeling is he’ll play on Saturday.” And he was keen to be clear on one thing: “I swear I’m not moaning.”

READ MORE: Hip-drop tackle yellow card: ‘What’s he supposed to do?’ asks Schalk Burger

The TMO and France’s 17 knee-drops

Erasmus’s strongest words were about the France game. He claimed France got away with 17 knee-drop tackles in their 21–19 win over the Springboks in Paris on Friday, and that the TMO did not step in once (Rassie on the France defeat).

“If he didn’t see it, it must be a technology problem,” Erasmus said. “If he saw it and decided not to act on it, is that not match-fixing?” He went further: “Is that not interfering with the outcome of a game?” If a TMO saw foul play and ignored it, he said, that pointed to manipulation of the game or the result, or to players getting hurt.

When it was put to him that this was a serious suggestion, he said twice: “It’s not an accusation.” His ask was simpler. “So all I’m asking, don’t take TMOs out and discourage them to get involved,” he said. “Then the wrong team will win and players will get injured. That’s all I’m saying.”

Of the 17 knee-drops, Erasmus said 11 were “at least a penalty” and three were “at least yellow card”. None was sanctioned or cited. He also claimed France scrum-half Maxime Lucu spent only seven minutes in the sin bin, not the full 10.

He later put the same question about Saturday’s tackle on Yato. If the TMO missed it, he said, that was a different story. If he saw it and ignored it, he asked what that was.

Hip-drop is not an automatic red card

Erasmus’s “immediate red card” view is not how the sanction works on paper. Under World Rugby’s guidance, the sanction for a hip-drop depends on the level of danger. Wallabies prop Angus Bell was the first player shown a card for one this month, a yellow for his tackle on England’s Immanuel Feyi-Waboso, and he was not cited afterwards.

Prendergast’s case will set the first marker for what a hip-drop citing costs. Ireland v South Africa kicks off at 4.40pm GMT (6.40pm in South Africa) on Saturday 21 November (why Dublin has not been a happy hunting ground for Rassie).

EXPLOSIVE Rassie Erasmus on the France LOSS, the TMO and TEAM for Ireland | Springboks PresserVideo · plays from YouTube

READ MORE: Ireland v South Africa: the last five meetings in Dublin

Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?