Skip to content

Ewen McKenzie: Rugby ‘Might As Well Get Rid Of’ The Scrum

Former Wallabies head coach Ewen McKenzie has said rugby 'might as well get rid of' the scrum, arguing that free kicks have left it with no real contest.

Ewen McKenzie, the former Wallabies head coach and prop, in a Wallabies rain jacket.

Former Wallabies head coach Ewen McKenzie has said rugby “might as well get rid of” the scrum, arguing that free kicks left no real contest in Scotland’s 15-12 win over Australia.

He said the referee watched only the Scottish flanker, and “the minute the guy lifted, he just blew the free kick”.

“So you might as well just get rid of it,” the former Wallabies prop said on Rugby Unity. “I don’t want to say that, but… you might as well get rid of it because it’s not serving any purpose.”

Is McKenzie right that free kicks have taken the contest out of the scrum? Tell us in the comments.

READ MORE: Scotland v Australia stats: both scrums won all their own ball, and one line break to ten

Ewen McKenzie: ‘there’s no scrum’ behind the stats

McKenzie was speaking with host David Pembroke and former All Blacks head coach Steve Hansen.

McKenzie said the half-time stats gave both sides “100 per cent of their scrums”. There had “only been five scrums”, he said, and “a couple of free kicks and a penalty”.

He said the scrum had also been an issue in France’s 21-19 win over the Springboks in Paris, after which Rassie Erasmus said the Springboks were wrong to chase scrum penalties.

Back at Murrayfield, McKenzie said he was not sure where the free kicks went in the stats.

“…they’re just counted as a scrum win. But there’s no scrum,” he said.

McKenzie said the scrum was the best attacking opportunity on the field, and the ball was not getting in and out of it.

“…it’s just too easy to go to the free kicks…” he said.

The referee ‘just blew the free kick’, says McKenzie

“He stood there and looked over the halfback’s shoulder… And the minute the guy lifted, he just blew the free kick,” McKenzie said.

A halfback is a scrum-half.

He said the scrum was meant to be an eight-on-eight contest, and there was work to be done there.

“…for the technical people like myself, it’s frustrating, and you’re not getting an outcome anyway,” McKenzie said.

Hansen warned that getting rid of the scrum would change the game.

“We’d change our game. We’re not a game for all shapes and sizes,” he said.

McKenzie also counted Australia’s box kicks at Murrayfield.

READ MORE: Ewen McKenzie: Wallabies ‘got none of the box kicks back’

READ MORE: James Parsons on Springboks scrums: why he would ‘go to the corner’ every time

THE NORTH DOMINATES! Wales beat New Zealand & France trump Springboks: Steve Hansen reacts!Video · plays from YouTube
Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Harry Wilson, in a red scrum cap, makes a tackle on a Scotland player at Murrayfield
Next up

Harry Wilson: Wallabies ‘want results, too’ after Scotland loss

Harry Wilson says the Wallabies are “not happy with competing hard and losing” after the 15–12 defeat at Murrayfield, and explains why he thinks more wins are coming.

Australia · 2 min read

More on Australia

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?