Skip to content

James Parsons: ‘I’d Go To The Corner’ Over Springboks Scrums

Former All Blacks hooker James Parsons has said scrums are "so 50/50" that he would go to the corner "every time", after the Springboks kept choosing the scrum in their 21-19 defeat to France.

Springbok prop Ox Nche at the Stade de France.

Former All Blacks hooker James Parsons has said scrums are “so 50/50” that he would go to the corner “every time”, after the Springboks kept choosing the scrum in their 21-19 defeat to France.

South Africa won every scrum and every lineout in Paris and still lost, after France scored all 21 of their points before half-time and Jasper Wiese was sent off in the 43rd minute (match report and full stats). Rassie Erasmus admitted after the match that one of the “wrong decisions” was “maybe kicking for corner rather than expecting the referee to give four penalties in a row”.

Parsons was speaking on the Aotearoa Rugby Pod with host Ross Karl and former Crusaders scrum-half Bryn Hall. He thought the Springboks were probably owed the penalties. He would still have gone to touch.

Were the Springboks right to keep going to the scrum? Tell us in the comments.

Parsons says nobody really knows who brought it down

Parsons had his own scrum complaint from the All Blacks’ 35-28 defeat to Wales in Cardiff.

“He gave us a penalty when he said, you know, you went in and down or whatever… and then we chose to scrum,” he said. “I always get nervous when you do that because scrums are so 50/50. You actually don’t know who’s brought it down, mate.”

Parsons said the referee then ruled against the All Blacks for a removed bind, and that the replay showed no such thing.

“The whole replay, he did not move his bind,” he said. “The loosehead’s job is to drive up. Tighthead’s job is to hit down. If it’s gone down, it’s the loosehead who’s just cranked on the elbow.”

Parsons says leaders must stop gambling on the scrum

Parsons said the answer for a dominant pack is to stop gambling on referees.

“I just think let it go. Stop the countless penalties. Unless you’re getting marched, penalised,” he said. “But you’ve got to be smarter in terms of those decisions as leaders. Scrums are so 50/50. I’d go to the corner every time.”

He admitted the hooker in him would argue the other way, because his job was to “challenge the referee”. “But as an analyst, this is where scrums have been heading for a long time,” he said.

Why it ‘frustrates every South African’

Hall had raised the question first, saying he thought “the referee put his whistle away” for the last scrum. Parsons accepted the Springboks had a case.

“Should they have been rewarded? Most probably yes,” he said. “But that is not where World Rugby are taking scrums and that frustrates every South African. I get it, because you’re very good at it.”

Erasmus made a similar point after the match, saying “it’s just human not to keep on penalising if they’ve already got a card or two for that”.

Parsons thought the penalties were probably there. He just would not have banked on getting them.

Ireland next, and the same choice in Dublin

South Africa play Ireland at the Aviva Stadium on Saturday 21 November (Ireland v South Africa preview). Ireland’s scrum and lineout both won all their own ball against Fiji last weekend (Ireland player ratings v Fiji).

The panel split on the result in Dublin. Parsons had already given his answer for the next scrum penalty inside the 22: the corner.

Did Wales Expose a Deeper All Blacks Problem? | ARPVideo · plays from YouTube
Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

France attack the Springboks defence at the Stade de France during France 21-19 South Africa on 13 November 2026.
Next up

Springboks ‘So Honest’ In Kick Chase: McKenzie Wonders Why

Former Wallabies head coach Ewen McKenzie has said the Springboks were 'so honest' in their kick chase against France that he is 'wondering what's coming'.

South Africa · 2 min read

More on South Africa

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?