Sir John Kirwan says Richie Mo’unga is “probably not” in an All Blacks Test spot right now, and he blames three years in Japan.
“He’ll want to be fighting for a Test spot, and I think at the moment he’s probably not in that position,” Kirwan said.
The former All Blacks wing was talking to Victor Matfield, the former Springboks lock, on the Rugby Rivals podcast.
Mo’unga started at 10 in Cardiff on Saturday, when Wales won 35-28 for their first win over New Zealand since 1953.
Is Kirwan right, or should Mo’unga keep the 10 jersey at Twickenham? Tell us in the comments.
Why Kirwan thinks Japan cost Richie Mo’unga
Matfield raised it. He wanted to know if Cardiff was “a red light” for Mo’unga, who he said had not had “any great games since he’s back”.
“I don’t think you can go to another country, especially Japan, and then come back in that position,” Kirwan replied. “I think it’s easier for other positions to come back.”
He said Ardie Savea and Beauden Barrett could come back from Japan, “but they went on sabbaticals. Richie went for three years.”
Mo’unga spent three seasons with Toshiba Brave Lupus and won back-to-back titles in Japan’s League One.
He came home for Canterbury in the NPC, New Zealand’s provincial competition, and in August won his first Test call-up since 2023.
READ MORE: How we rated Mo’unga and every All Black in Cardiff
‘It took me six months’: Kirwan’s own Japan lesson
Kirwan played in Japan and later coached the national team. “I remember when I first went to Japan, it took me six months to adjust to the style of play,” he said.
He said the game “changes really quick, and it’s changed since he left”. Injuries have not helped either.
“He’s had a couple of injuries, he hasn’t had much of a flow-on, and he’s been given a couple of big opportunities, and it hasn’t worked out for him.”
Is Kirwan writing Mo’unga off?
No. “The quality is there. I’m not worried about that,” Kirwan said. “I think he’ll adjust. I’ve got no issues with that.”
Who wears 10 at Twickenham?
For now, Dave Rennie has a side to pick for England, and his backline is already short.
Centre Quinn Tupaea is out with a fractured thumb, and Will Jordan is still racing a hamstring injury.
Rennie names his side later this week. England v New Zealand kicks off at 2.10pm GMT on Saturday 21 November.
A bonus-point win would put the All Blacks in the Nations Championship final. Will Mo’unga be wearing 10?
READ MORE: Dave Rennie floats Japanese clubs joining Super Rugby
READ MORE: Victor Matfield calls the hip-drop law ‘another crazy stupid law’
Sir John Kirwan and Victor Matfield were speaking on the Rugby Rivals podcast, published on 17 November 2026. Watch the full discussion.










Comments
No one has weighed in yet.
Be the first - what did you make of it?