Skip to content

Victor Matfield: Hip-Drop Tackle Ban Is A ‘Crazy Stupid Law’

The Springboks great says the law leaves tacklers nowhere to go. John Kirwan says the hip-drop law is about player safety, and he backs it.

Victor Matfield holding a microphone pitchside as a rugby pundit

Victor Matfield has called the hip-drop tackle law “another crazy stupid law”. Sir John Kirwan took the other side: “Do I agree with it? Yeah. I do agree with it.”

On Rugby Rivals, the two were asked about Rassie Erasmus and his complaints about the officiating in France’s 21-19 win over the Springboks in Paris.

“I don’t know where you can tackle these days anymore,” Matfield said. “You’re not allowed to hit up high. You’re not allowed to use your knees on the ground before you tackle.”

Whose side are you on, Matfield or Kirwan? Tell us in the comments.

Why Matfield says the hip-drop tackle law is ‘crazy’

Matfield said he understood Erasmus’s point. If the law is a focus, he said, “referees and TMOs should come in and they should officiate it”.

“But I just think it’s another crazy stupid law coming in,” he said.

He had also watched the tackle by Ireland fly-half Sam Prendergast that Erasmus questioned. “There’s nothing in it for me. I can’t believe that someone should miss a game because of it.”

READ MORE: Rassie Erasmus expects ‘a technicality’ to save Prendergast

Why Kirwan backs the law

“Look, I think it’s about the health and safety of the players,” Kirwan said.

He compared it with the jackal law, which lets a player win the ball on the ground after a tackle. The All Blacks were “fantastic at it” within about six months, he said.

“It probably took Italy five years to adjust,” said Kirwan, a former Italy head coach.

His worry is timing, with the change coming “sort of mid-season”.

He still wants patience while players adapt. “I just think there needs to be a little bit of understanding and leeway,” he said.

So what is a hip-drop tackle?

Matfield asked Kirwan to explain it. Kirwan said it happens when a tackler grabs a runner from behind, or tries to recover, and leaps and swings.

“Your weight is actually hitting against the bottom of his legs, which then can cause him to buckle and twist his ankle and his knee.”

Matfield’s answer: if a runner is through, a defender has no other way to stop him. “There’s no intent in that,” he said.

Schalk Burger made the same point after Angus Bell’s yellow card.

Hip drop or knee drop? The 17 tackles

Matfield said Erasmus counted 17 in one game. Most reports say Erasmus’s 17 were knee-drop tackles, where a tackler drops onto a knee into the runner.

World Rugby has cracked down on knee drops and hip drops this autumn. They are separate offences.

Erasmus said the TMO, the video referee, did not step in once. He went further and asked, “is that not match-fixing?”

That question has cost him. The podcast was recorded before World Rugby banned Erasmus for six matches on Tuesday, and SA Rugby has asked for a full hearing.

He misses Saturday’s Test against Ireland in Dublin, which kicks off at 4.40pm GMT. Will the TMO step in this time?

READ MORE: John Kirwan: Richie Mo’unga ‘probably not’ in a Test spot

Sir John Kirwan and Victor Matfield were speaking on the Rugby Rivals podcast, published on 17 November 2026. Watch the full discussion.

All Blacks & Springboks Beaten! JK & Victor React to Rugby’s Wildest WeekendVideo · plays from YouTube
Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

John Kirwan Says Three All Blacks Defeats In A Row Are Learnings, Not Losses. Victor Matfield Says He Has Stopped Caring About Winning.
Next up

John Kirwan Says Three All Blacks Defeats In A Row Are Learnings, Not Losses. Victor Matfield Says He Has Stopped Caring About Winning.

John Kirwan calls three All Blacks defeats in a row learnings, names two locks, and backs Dave Rennie even if England win. Matfield says he no longer cares.

New Zealand · 8 min read

More on South Africa

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?