Skip to content

Malcolm Marx fist clip with Antoine Dupont sparks ban calls

The clip from France's 21-19 win has split fans. Some call it a cheap shot, others say the Springboks hooker was bracing for a knee-slide.

Malcolm Marx's left hand goes towards Antoine Dupont as the France scrum-half slides in, France v South Africa, Stade de France
Image: Nations Championship / Instagram

Footage appears to show Springboks hooker Malcolm Marx’s closed fist making contact with Antoine Dupont on the last play of France’s 21-19 win in Paris. Some fans want him banned. Nobody has been cited, and WalesOnline reports the usual window to cite him has now passed.

Some fans call it a cheap shot. South Africans say Marx was bracing because Dupont was sliding in at his knees.

Was it a strike, or a hooker protecting himself? Tell us in the comments.

Watch the incident below ↓

What does the Malcolm Marx footage show?

It happened on the final play of the round 5 Nations Championship Test at the Stade de France on Friday 13 November. Marx had just passed the ball. As Dupont approached, the hooker looked his way, clenched his left hand and moved his arm towards the France scrum-half.

There is not much force in it. The match officials took no action at the time.

The Nations Championship’s own reel of the passage is below. Watch Marx’s left hand as Dupont slides in.

Slowed-down versions have spread on X and Instagram this week. “Once their fist closes and moves forward, it’s intentional,” one fan wrote, in a post quoted by WalesOnline.

Why Springboks fans say Marx was only bracing

South African supporters point to how Dupont went into the contact. “Dupont is literally sliding into his knee caps in an illegal tackle,” one wrote.

The Rugby Issue account on X said it had seen calls for a citing. It called the closed fist “a natural action for creating separation and breaking a tackle”.

That defence leans on the knee-slide row Rassie Erasmus started after the defeat. Erasmus said France made 17 of those tackles. Brian O’Driscoll went back through the tape and counted five in the first half, all from flanker François Cros, and called 17 “fanciful”.

Can World Rugby still ban Marx?

Probably not. WalesOnline says there is no sign of a formal investigation. With the citing window gone, a ban through the standard process is no longer expected.

It comes in a bad week for the Boks at the judiciary. Head coach Rassie Erasmus was banned for six matches over his comments about the match officials. No 8 Jasper Wiese got four matches for the clear-out on Kalvin Gourgues that was upgraded to a 20-minute red card.

South Africa now go to Dublin to face Ireland at the Aviva Stadium on Saturday 21 November, kick-off 4.40pm GMT.

READ MORE: O’Driscoll counts five knee-slides, Erasmus claimed 17

Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

A France player at the Stade de France during the 21-19 win over South Africa
Next up

France vs South Africa Match Report And Full Stats: Les Bleus Hold On 21-19 Against The Springboks

France held off South Africa 21-19 at the Stade de France. Report, timeline, every team and player stat, and line-ups.

France · 5 min read

More on France

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?