Skip to content
News

O’Driscoll counts five knee-slides – Erasmus claimed 17

François Cros of France raising his arm to the crowd

He watched the first half of the France game on one camera and says World Rugby’s angles will settle the number.

Brian O’Driscoll says he found five knee-slide tackles by France in the Springboks game, and calls the figure of 17 that Rassie Erasmus has put forward “fanciful”. The former Ireland and British & Irish Lions centre reviewed the first half on one camera and gave his count on Newstalk’s Rugby on Off the Ball. Is it five, 17, or does the number miss the point?

What he counted

O’Driscoll said he went through the first half of the game in detail and picked out five tackles by France back row François Cros that looked knee-first into the collision.

He was careful about what those five were. “He didn’t make contact in every situation,” he said. In one, Cros slides in from a metre and a half out without making any real effort at a tackle. O’Driscoll compared it with a moment late in the game when Antoine Dupont tackled Marx. If Dupont had tackled in that manner, “that’s an absolute clear-cut penalty”, he said.

The one that stood out

The clearest example, he said, came when Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu made a break. Damian de Allende was hit late and chopped at the knees, and did a small somersault after a slide tackle from Cros.

“That’s exactly the type of tackle that World Rugby are trying to outlaw,” O’Driscoll said.

How he judges a slide

Because the sport is in “new territory” on this, he said the question is timing. Does the knee hit the ground and the collision follow almost at the same moment, or does the player lead with the slide and tackle afterwards?

That is the same grey area behind the hip-drop debate over Sam Prendergast.

Why he says 17 is too many

“So whether there were 17, I think that’s fanciful to say that there were that many,” O’Driscoll said. He then listed the limits of his own count. He had one camera, while World Rugby and the teams have multiple angles. They are “probably better positioned” to say how accurate the 17 is.

He added that there may have been several attempted tackles that were not completed but still looked like knee-slides. “I presume he’s included those in the 17,” he said.

Frustration, with a condition

O’Driscoll said he understands the frustration. Watching live, he thought a few knee drops looked to be coming in, and the referee moved on. He agreed there had been some poor officiating and decision-making.

His condition is how it is said. He thinks the complaint was lost in the language Erasmus used.

Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?