Tying a card to whether the tackled player goes off could reward the wrong behaviour, the former Ireland centre says.
Brian O’Driscoll says sanctioning a tackle by what happens to the player on the receiving end could push players to stay down and feign injury. He raised it on Newstalk’s Rugby on Off the Ball after the citing committee cleared Ireland fly-half Sam Prendergast, whose tackle only came to light because the Fijian captain went off hurt. Should a card depend on whether the injured player comes off?
Why the injury mattered
O’Driscoll said the tackle would have been “quite unlikely” to be picked up if the Fijian captain had not left the field. That, he said, makes the process outcome-based, and he warned of the knock-on effect.
“The last thing we want to do is encourage players to stay down feigning any level of injury to bring the attention to the TMO, to the referee,” he said. For the most part, he added, rugby players do not behave that way. Players do jump up after tackles and are not injured.
The head injury problem
He said a lower-leg injury is different from a head or high shot. Raise a head concern with a referee and it goes to an HIA. O’Driscoll said the process is “very difficult to pass these days”, so a player can end up withdrawn from the game.
In a leg case, he said, the player can get up and run off a knee or ankle problem once the referee has dealt with the tackler by yellow or red card.
Standardise it
His conclusion: “You’re in slightly dangerous territory around getting locked into an outcome-based decision-making process rather than being standardised across the board depending on the severity of that tackle.”
He said rugby is on a “learning curve trajectory” over hip drops, over what grades as a penalty, a yellow or a red, and whether that turns on the level of injury, on continued participation, or whether it will be standardised. His full argument on why the tackle was cleared is in a separate piece.
‘The last nation’ to feign
O’Driscoll said Fijian players are probably the last he would expect to consider feigning an injury. He called them “tough as nails” and said he remembers hearing a surgeon describe the strength of a Fijian player’s ligaments. He stressed he is “not saying across the board”. The point was about this player: he got up and finished the try before going off.
Context for the debate is in his comments on Rassie Erasmus and the knee-slide row, where he said World Rugby are “in new territory”.




Comments
No one has weighed in yet.
Be the first - what did you make of it?