The Ireland fly-half’s hip drop is what World Rugby wants outlawed, but a locked-on arm gave the panel its doubt.
Brian O’Driscoll says Sam Prendergast’s tackle on the Fijian captain would be a red card “in isolation”, and that only Andrew Porter’s locked-on left arm explains why the Ireland fly-half escaped a ban. A three-person citing committee unanimously dismissed the citing, and the former Ireland and British & Irish Lions centre explained why on Newstalk’s Rugby on Off the Ball. Was the committee right to clear Prendergast?
What the committee decided
The host read out the outcome. The committee met the night before and unanimously found that Prendergast had proved, to the required standard, that the citing should be dismissed. It heard evidence from Prendergast, a submission from IRFU solicitor Derek Hegarty and one from Ireland head coach Andy Farrell.
O’Driscoll changed his mind
O’Driscoll said he missed the tackle live and only looked again after Rassie Erasmus’s comments. He did not realise at first that the Fijian captain’s injury came from it.
At an event the night before the result, he suggested there was a good chance of some form of ban, given the pressure Erasmus had put on World Rugby and the committee. By the next morning he thought a good lawyer could change that.
The two-step argument
His first step is that the tackle is a hip drop. “He does bring his weight down onto” the Fijian captain, O’Driscoll said, and that is “exactly the type of tackle they’re trying to outlaw”. Take Andrew Porter out of the picture and “it’s going to be a red card” for Sam Prendergast.
His second step is Porter, whose left arm was locked on to Prendergast. O’Driscoll said the job of counsel was to argue for a plausible alternative, that the force Porter exerted could have brought Prendergast down. “We’ll never know,” he said, but that was enough for a panel to side with the mitigation.
That would cut a red card to a yellow, so there would be no suspension to serve after the game. O’Driscoll noted it is “not legal speak” and that he has not sat in many hearings. He has been in one “in the dock”, and has sat in as a reference for others.
Two views of the same tackle
The host’s own reference point was Angus Bell’s yellow card the week before. He had assumed Prendergast’s tackle was a yellow-card defence, and that a ban needs red-card level.
O’Driscoll said the result will land differently by country. “From an Irish point of view, you’re happy with that. From a South African point of view, you’ll feel hard done by.” He expects South Africa to call it nonsense. He wants to hear what English, French and New Zealand viewers make of it, because the emotion has to come out of it.
His wider point is that rugby is “in new territory” with hip drops. The tackles have always happened. Now they are scrutinised and outlawed, and the sport is on a “learning curve” over what earns a penalty, a yellow or a red. He raised the risk that injury could decide the sanction.




Comments
No one has weighed in yet.
Be the first - what did you make of it?