Rassie Erasmus’s late team changes are turning team naming into “a little bit of a farce”, according to Aotearoa Rugby Pod host Ross Karl, who says World Rugby has “created a farce, which makes your whole setup look stupid”.
The Springboks named Ox Nché, Malcolm Marx and Wilco Louw as their starting front row on Monday. About an hour before kick-off at the Stade de France on Friday, Jan-Hendrik Wessels, Gerhard Steenekamp and Thomas du Toit started instead, and France won 21-19 (match report and full stats).
The panel said France answered with a late change of their own at hooker, Peato Mauvaka. Karl raised it on the Aotearoa Rugby Pod with former All Blacks hooker James Parsons and former Crusaders scrum-half Bryn Hall. Parsons disagreed with Karl.
Is a late change smart coaching or a farce? Tell us in the comments.
Karl says late changes kill the point of team naming
Karl argued that the 48-hour team announcement exists to sell the game.
“One of the main reasons why there’s a team naming 48 hours beforehand is promotion of the game,” he said. Players and coaches, he explained, then do interviews about the match.
“If every team did that, what the French did, what the South Africans did every week, team naming would become a joke. No one would trust it.”
“Name your team, play your team, or don’t name your team,” he said. “Name your team an hour before the game.”
Karl blames World Rugby’s own rules
Karl read out the rule. “World Rugby’s regulation 15.12 requires unions to announce and exchange their starting 15s and up to eight replacements 48 hours out from the game,” he said. “The rules of the Nations Championship: one hour out, you have to have the final squad named.”
“The rules have been set up to create the farce. World Rugby’s got to take this on the chin, too. You’ve created a farce, which makes your whole setup look stupid.”
He said the cost falls on fans, who believe what coaches tell them. “They trust that you’re telling them the truth.”
Karl added that a coach who explains a selection early in the week, knowing it will change, loses him as a viewer. “Me as a person who watches the game, I’m gonna be like, ‘Well, I don’t believe anything you say, so why am I gonna tune into this press conference?'”
“But it makes me disconnect from him,” he continued. “It makes me go, ‘Well, I don’t like that guy, ’cause he’s lying to me.'”
Erasmus has said the switch was decided on the Thursday, after the side was named on the Monday, and that “up until the captain’s practice yesterday we weren’t quite sure”.
Parsons says Rassie has found a loophole
Parsons backed Erasmus.
“I credit Rassie. He’s found a loophole,” he said. “And he’s exploiting it, and it’s fine. It’s in the rules. Go for it.”
“I’m sort of starting to lean towards I like it,” he added. “But I am in a very strange mood today.”
Parsons and Hall then admitted they had pulled the same trick at North Harbour. On a short turnaround against Canterbury, they named a standard side and then made five or six changes, with Shaun Stevenson at fly-half. One of them told the coach at the time that a new 10 would mean nothing to the opposition, because the systems stay the same.
South Africa, a point behind New Zealand in the Southern Hemisphere table, face Ireland in Dublin in the final round on Saturday 21 November.












Comments
No one has weighed in yet.
Be the first - what did you make of it?