Skip to content

Simon Zebo Calls World Rugby’s Hip-Drop Stance ‘Bizarre’

The former Ireland back welcomes the crackdown on hip-drop tackles, but says a big new rule means little if it is not backed up.

Ireland players line up for the anthem at the Aviva Stadium
The Ireland team stand for the national anthem ahead of the 2025 Guinness Six Nations Championship Round 1 between Ireland and England in Aviva Stadium, Dublin, Ireland, Saturday, February 1, 2025 (Photo by Ben Brady / Inpho)

Simon Zebo thinks the hip-drop tackle should go, but he wants World Rugby to follow through. “I don’t understand how they don’t,” the former Ireland back said of outlawing it, calling a big rule announcement with nothing behind it “bizarre to me”. Should World Rugby ban the hip-drop tackle outright?

The hosts put the new rule to Zebo after Ireland fly-half Sam Prendergast was named as the first player cited under it, a point they said “feels seismic” in how players are tackling one another. They also described Prendergast as “getting off with the citing”, but Zebo’s answer did not turn on that outcome. It was about the rule itself, and what happens to it now. Zebo, a former Ireland and Munster back, said the effect on coaching would be immediate.

What does the hip-drop rule change for coaches?

“Yeah, it’s just a new thing to train,” Zebo said. “It’s a new thing that you’re going to have to coach.”

He thinks the sport will gain from it. “I suppose it’ll benefit the game,” he said, citing the number of injuries the tackle causes.

Why does Zebo see injuries as the reason to act?

His concern is about what happens if the tackle stays in the game. “There’s going to be more problems from keeping that type of tackle in the game, especially lower limb,” Zebo said.

Zebo said he had spoken recently to two pundits about a serious leg injury from the tackle, but gave no details here.

Is World Rugby doing enough?

Zebo’s welcome is conditional, and that is the sharpest part of his answer. He said it is “a good thing for the game that it’s going to be outlawed”, then added the catch: “But World Rugby has to then outlaw it. I don’t understand how they don’t.”

He described the problem as an announcement without a follow-up. A big new rule change followed by nothing, he said, “is bizarre to me”.

Zebo did not say what World Rugby should do or by when, and he did not criticise any individual official. His point is about follow-through.

How does this link to the Rassie Erasmus row?

The hip-drop question came straight after Zebo’s defence of Rassie Erasmus. On that, Zebo said what he understood Rassie to want was “par for everybody”. Zebo did not link the two topics himself, but both answers turn on decisions being applied evenly.

Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?