Skip to content

Dave Rennie Paused The Tape On Bad Calls, Says Brad Weber

Brad Weber explains why Dave Rennie lets a skill error go but stops the video on a wrong decision, and what he thinks the All Blacks will find from Cardiff.

All Blacks head coach Dave Rennie at an All Blacks media conference
Photo: Sport Nation

Brad Weber says Dave Rennie is “okay to live with” a skill error. A wrong decision is different. “He’ll pause it at the exact moment that you made that bad decision,” Weber said of his old coach.

On the All Blacks’ Inside The Black Jersey, Weber said he expects the same in the review of the 35–28 loss to Wales. Which is worse in a Test: a dropped pass or the wrong call?

READ MORE: Dave Rennie Admits All Blacks Were ‘Out-Passioned’ By Wales

Why Dave Rennie lets a dropped pass go but stops the tape on a wrong call

Weber said that when he was coached by Rennie, “a lot of the time if the decision is right, he’s okay to live with the skill set perhaps not being quite where it needs to be”.

If the decision was wrong, the video stops, and Rennie asks the player directly: “But Brad, what were you thinking here?”

Asked what he would do next time, Weber’s example answer was: “Next time I’m going to make sure I actually sight the man there rather than just throwing it blindly, making sure that it’s not just a 50/50. It’s more like an 80/20.”

Rennie might then say “Great, move on.” Or, Weber said, “maybe he’d get into it deeper and deeper”.

“If it’s decision-making stuff, that’s where the whole team can learn,” he said. A skill error is “pretty easy” for an individual to fix.

Never the full replay: inside an All Blacks review

Weber said the week starts with a Monday morning team meeting, then backs and forwards split before the gym. The review is “mostly coach-led”. Under Ian Foster and Steve Hansen, he said, “you’re all in a semicircle” around a big projector screen. He is “not sure if [Rennie] has carried that on”.

“You never watch the full replay,” he said. The coaches pick clips tied to that week’s focus areas. Skill work is done one-on-one with the coach in charge of that position group, “whether that’s Dave Rennie or Mike Blair”.

Three or four tries left out there, says Weber

Weber imagined Rennie would be looking at the offloads and passes that “didn’t quite go to hand”, and asking whether the decision was right.

“There were times where our tunnel vision really got us,” Weber said, “where rather than just carrying, if we were able to make that one extra pass we would have walked in for a try.” He counted “probably three or four occasions” that the players will “go back and look” at.

He also thought the team had been told to keep it tight after halftime, and “ironically perhaps the team maybe took that a bit too far”.

Rennie himself said his side failed to do the obvious against Wales. Sir John Kirwan called it a “mental lapse” and used Gilbert Enoka’s phrase “red head”, for a player who panics and stops seeing what is in front of him.

READ MORE: All Blacks v England ‘Season Defining’, Says John Kirwan

Steve Hansen said the All Blacks “could have just pulled the trigger and gone out the back and walked over”.

15 turnovers: bad decisions or bad hands?

The All Blacks had 64.7% of the ball, carried 260 times to Wales’ 119 and beat 36 defenders to 19. They also gave the ball away 15 times to Wales’ seven, according to our Wales v New Zealand match report.

The official figures do not say how many of those 15 were bad decisions and how many were bad hands. That is the question Weber imagines Rennie asking of the passes that didn’t go to hand.

Rennie said after the match that his side “got out-passioned” and that he needs to see “a response at Twickenham next week”. England v New Zealand kicks off at 2.10pm GMT on Saturday 21 November.

Will the extra pass be there at Twickenham? Tell us in the comments.

What Really Happens in an All Blacks Review? | Inside The Black JerseyVideo · plays from YouTube

FAQ

What did Brad Weber say about Dave Rennie’s reviews? On the All Blacks’ Inside The Black Jersey, published on 18 November 2026, Weber said that when Rennie coached him, Rennie could live with a skill error if the decision was right. If the decision was wrong, he would pause the video at that moment and ask the player what he was thinking.

When do the All Blacks play England? England v New Zealand kicks off at 2.10pm GMT on Saturday 21 November at Twickenham.

Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Dave Rennie speaking at an All Blacks press conference
Next up

Dave Rennie on Wales loss: ‘You’re not a Kiwi, are you?’

Asked whether the All Blacks' first defeat to Wales since 1953 still mattered with England next, Dave Rennie had a question for the reporter.

Wales · 2 min read

More on New Zealand

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?