Skip to content

Wales v New Zealand: did Wales win it or the All Blacks lose it?

Kick Offs and Kick Ons credited the Welsh pack. Dave Rennie blamed his own side's finishing. Here are both cases, and a warning for the Wallabies.

Wales players celebrate at full time against the All Blacks
Photo: Sky News via The Sporting Base

“I didn’t think the All Blacks were off. Wales were just phenomenal.” That was one KOKO panellist’s verdict on Wales v New Zealand, a 35-28 Welsh win in Cardiff. It was Wales’ first win over the All Blacks since 1953.

The Australian Kick Offs and Kick Ons (KOKO) panel gave Wales the credit. All Blacks coach Dave Rennie has pointed at his own side.

Did Wales win it, or did the All Blacks lose it? Tell us in the comments.

READ MORE: Sam Warburton calls Wales’ defence against the All Blacks the most heroic

Wales v New Zealand: the case that Wales won it

One of the panel put it down to the Welsh pack. “It was all in the forwards,” he said, pointing to their intensity and physicality.

As an Australian, he had expected the All Blacks to come over the top, “because maybe that’s what’s happened to us so many times”.

“But they just like stayed strong and just kept going at them,” he said. “It was actually really impressive.”

Wales led 14-0 inside six minutes, and the All Blacks were level at 21-21 by half-time.

Later in the show, one of the panel came back to New Zealand. They had “been playing really well and Wales just aimed up”, he said. “It wasn’t like the ABs were shocking.”

The case that the All Blacks lost it

Dave Rennie has been harder on his own side. He admitted the All Blacks were out-passioned by Wales.

After the Test, he said his players created plenty of chances but were not clinical enough. New Zealand had 64.7 per cent of the ball and nine line breaks to five.

The panel also questioned New Zealand’s changes for Cardiff. In their view, there is no week off in Test rugby.

In New Zealand, the mood was grief. One TV pundit said the defeat felt “a little bit like a death in the family”.

So who gets the credit for Wales’ win?

The panel’s answer was Wales. One of them admitted he had expected New Zealand to pull away once they drew level. “I thought… this might be where they now kick on cuz the All Blacks go into another gear,” he said.

Instead, New Zealand did not score in the last 27 minutes.

Should the Wallabies be worried about Wales?

The panel think so. Wales play Australia next, and Les Kiss says every Test is must-win for his side.

One of the panel issued a warning for Saturday. Wales, he said, are “going to be hard to stop especially in that first 20 minutes for us if we let them get their tails up”.

WALLABIES IN FREEFALL! WALES SHOCK THE WORLD & TRAVIS HEAD JOINS THE CHAOS!Video · plays from YouTube

READ MORE: Wales player ratings v All Blacks: 9.5 for Tomos Williams

Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

A Wales defender tackles an All Blacks ball carrier in Cardiff
Next up

Dave Rennie: All Blacks failed to ‘do the obvious’ against Wales

The All Blacks head coach on the Cardiff review, tunnel vision under pressure and the ‘one more pass’ his side didn’t throw.

New Zealand · 2 min read

More on New Zealand

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?