Skip to content

Jake White warns Ireland of the scrum call Erasmus regretted

Fiji coach Jake White says the Springboks would take scrum after scrum against Ireland on 21 November. A day earlier, Rassie Erasmus said that plan cost them in Paris.

Jake White smiling in a navy cap

Jake White has told Ireland how the Springboks will try to beat them. The trouble is that Rassie Erasmus said the opposite a day earlier. Who has it right, the man who used to pick the Springboks or the man who picks them now? Tell us in the comments.

Fiji head coach Jake White, who won the 2007 World Cup with South Africa, said on 14 November that the Springboks would turn the five-metre chances Fiji wasted in their 43-15 defeat in Dublin into points when they play Ireland on 21 November.

“I think we probably did Ireland a favour today.”

Jake White, Fiji head coach, after the match

His case rests on scrums the Springboks would never turn down. Erasmus, after losing 21-19 in Paris, said chasing exactly those scrum penalties was a mistake. Saturday will show which of them read the referee right.

The tap White says Marx would never take

In the second half, with a penalty close to the Ireland line, Fiji tapped instead of taking the scrum. White said the Springboks would have packed down instead and backed themselves to draw a yellow card.

“They would have taken another scrum and another scrum and another scrum”, he said, adding that South Africa would not worry about the referee calling a collapse or an early engage.

With Malcolm Marx leading the pack, he said, the tap would never happen. Marx would want the scrum, or the corner and a lineout.

He said Ireland would be “up against it” if they played like that against South Africa. Fiji also wasted five-metre lineouts, and when his side went off script near the line, he said, a polished Irish team punished them.

What Erasmus said in Paris

Erasmus had already argued against it on 13 November. South Africa won every scrum against France, and France replacement prop Régis Montagne was sent to the bin in the 68th minute, but Erasmus said waiting for more scrum penalties was the wrong call.

“Maybe the call should have been let’s kick for touch and maul it rather, because it’s tough to give seven penalties in a row and another yellow card.”

Rassie Erasmus, 13 November

His reasoning was about the man with the whistle. A referee who has already shown two cards to the home side, in front of a full stadium, is slow to give a third. Ireland will be at home on 21 November.

The pack did get there in the end. Marx crashed over in the 71st minute, and Manie Libbok’s missed conversion left South Africa two points short.

The 55 minutes Ireland need to forget

The final score was 43-15, but the game stayed close for 55 minutes. Fiji led by five points after 25 minutes, and Ireland were only 17-15 up at half-time.

Ireland won the second half 26-0. Andrew Porter scored their fifth try, and Fiji never got back into it.

Andy Farrell, the Ireland head coach, said the score “flattered us a little bit”. He said the squad had talked in the changing room about lessons they would use against South Africa.

Erasmus: Fiji changed nothing

When Erasmus named his team in Dublin on 16 November, he was asked about the idea that Fiji had done Ireland a favour. He did not think the Fiji game would have any effect on Saturday. Ireland’s senior players had faced the Springboks many times, he said, and beaten them in Dublin most of the time.

On the scrum he was just as careful. “I don’t think Porter or Furlong is bad scrummagers,” he said. Later in the same answer he added: “Obviously we would love to have dominance there, but it doesn’t come just by hoping.”

Why Ireland won’t walk in blind

White thinks Farrell kept a strong side for Fiji to get Ireland “a little bit more gun-ready for next weekend”, rather than rotate. A side that prepares like that is not walking into Dublin blind.

He also laughed and told reporters not to write that he was predicting a Springboks hammering. His point was about what Ireland already know.

What happens next

Ireland v South Africa kicks off at 16:40 GMT on Saturday 21 November at the Aviva Stadium. The Springboks won 24-13 on their last visit, in November 2025.

Debutant James McNabney is out, after a head injury against Fiji left him facing 12 days of return-to-play protocols. Centre Jamie Osborne is likely to miss out too, with what looks like a pectoral injury. Fly-half Sam Prendergast has been cited for an alleged hip-drop on Fiji captain Peceli Yato. Malcolm Marx, the man White says would never take the tap, is named to start at hooker.

The table adds weight. Going into round 6, New Zealand lead South Africa by one point in the Southern Hemisphere table, and Ireland are level with England on 20, one behind France, in the north. Finals weekend at Allianz Stadium, Twickenham, runs from 27 to 29 November.

If Ireland concede a penalty five metres out in the last ten minutes, should the Springboks scrum again, as White says, or kick to the corner, as Erasmus now does?

Read next

Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Jamison Gibson-Park looks up from the base of a ruck for Ireland against Argentina in Dublin.
Next up

Ireland Team v Fiji: Keenan Out, ‘They Love To Hammer People’

Tadhg Beirne captains Ireland, Mack Hansen moves to 15 and Hugo Keenan is left out after his hat-trick: seven changes with the Springboks next.

Ireland · 3 min read

More on Ireland

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?