Skip to content

Siya Kolisi took the blame in Paris. Did it swing the cards?

Five cards in Paris, two to South Africa. Steven Kitshoff says it could have been three and none, and credits Siya Kolisi's talks with the referee.

Siya Kolisi celebrates in a Springboks jersey

Five cards in Paris. France got three of them.

Steven Kitshoff, the double World Cup-winning prop, said on For The Love Of Rugby: South Africa that the Springboks could easily have finished France’s 21-19 win on 13 November with two yellows and a red to France’s none. He credits Siya Kolisi‘s talks with referee Andrea Piardi for the difference. Was that leadership, or working the referee? Tell us in the comments.

One moment stood out to his co-host Ben Youngs, the former England scrum-half. When Malcolm Marx was penalised at a ruck, Youngs says, Kolisi told the referee it was his own fault and his responsibility.

On the night, Rassie Erasmus, sitting beside his captain, would not point at Piardi. “That’s why I’m saying I’m not blaming the ref,” the South Africa head coach said.

By Monday he had turned on the TMO instead. At his team announcement in Dublin he claimed France got away with 17 knee-drop tackles without the TMO stepping in once. “If he saw it and decided not to act on it, is that not match-fixing?” he asked, before adding twice: “It’s not an accusation.”

The card record

MinutePlayerCard
12Lood de Jager (SA)Yellow
39Maxime Lucu (FRA)Yellow
43Jasper Wiese (SA)Yellow upgraded to 20-minute red
49Aaron Grandidier-Nkanang (FRA)Yellow
68Régis Montagne (FRA)Yellow

Source: official match report.

France scored all 21 of their points before the break. South Africa won the second half 12-0, and Manie Libbok’s missed conversion of Marx’s 71st-minute try left them two short.

Why Kitshoff says Kolisi got France carded

Kitshoff’s example is consistency. De Jager’s 12th-minute yellow was for a high hit on Lucu. Kitshoff credits Kolisi with pressing the point that if a Springboks player is binned for a high hit, the same has to apply to France.

Lucu was carded himself in the 39th minute. Kitshoff thinks one of the French yellows, by our reading Lucu’s, was close to a penalty only, which makes the captain’s word more important, not less.

Youngs and the McCaw comparison

Youngs says Kolisi was challenging decisions and asking the right questions all night, with the crowd going berserk around him. He reached for Richie McCaw’s influence on referees, while saying the two are different characters, and called it leadership at its highest.

Kitshoff agreed. He says Kolisi has become brilliant at getting his message across to a referee as time has gone on. Our piece on how Kolisi runs a room shows where that comes from.

Kolisi kept his own post-match words short. “So yeah, we know what we need to fix,” he said.

But talking didn’t stop 11 penalties

Kolisi played 57 minutes. Montagne, the replacement prop, was carded in the 68th minute, after Kolisi had gone off. That is the stretch Kitshoff says Pieter-Steph du Toit usually leads.

And talking well did not stop South Africa conceding 11 penalties and losing. South Africa had 55% possession, out-gained France by 598 metres to 309 and won every scrum and lineout, as the full match report shows. The cards were the one count they lost.

What happens next

Ireland host South Africa at the Aviva Stadium on Saturday 21 November (4.40pm GMT) in round 6. Kolisi is named to captain the side again, and Eben Etzebeth returns at lock. The Springboks team page has the full 23.

If Kolisi talks the referee into carding an Ireland player on Saturday, is that the best leadership in the game, or exactly what Erasmus was complaining about on Monday?

Read next

Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

France players celebrate at the end of their 21-19 win over the Springboks at the Stade de France as South Africa players look on.
Next up

Springboks lineout offside went unpunished twice, says McKenzie

Springboks lineout offside went unpunished twice in their 21-19 defeat to France, according to former Wallabies head coach Ewen McKenzie.

South Africa · 2 min read

More on France

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?