Skip to content

Ben Youngs: Rennie used Wales as a ‘pool game experiment’

England’s most capped player explains why November Tests are for experiments, and what he wants to see from England against the All Blacks.

England's Ollie Chessum running in to score against France in the Six Nations at the Stade de France
Photo: Getty Images via Evening Standard

Ben Youngs says Dave Rennie’s rotation for Wales was “very similar to what England just did against Japan”. Wales won 35-28 on Saturday 14 November, their first victory over New Zealand since 1953.

England’s most capped player told the Aotearoa Rugby Pod why Steve Borthwick could change so much against Japan: “Northern hemisphere, Six Nations is everything. You don’t experiment in the Six Nations. It just doesn’t happen.”

Six Nations rugby arrives after New Zealand and one more round, he said. Was Rennie right to experiment against Wales, or did it cost the All Blacks? Tell us in the comments.

READ MORE: Dave Rennie on picking the All Blacks side for Wales

Ben Youngs: Six Nations is why England experimented against Japan

Youngs called Japan “the perfect example”. Borthwick made “a bucketload of changes”, he said, and players got opportunities.

England kept experienced players in the group and added youngsters, he said. With a World Cup less than a year away, it was a chance to look at potential slots for players.

“So you had to make the time to do it. It was Japan.”

Did Dave Rennie’s ‘experiment’ cost the All Blacks against Wales?

“Dave Rennie can rotate against Wales, almost use it as a World Cup pool game experiment.”

New Zealand had beaten Scotland convincingly, Youngs said, so from the outside Scotland looked the harder game. Wales were “that middle game where they’ve got an eye on England”.

He added that there was still serious calibre in the side, with “gold dust” in the squad.

And he agreed it was the right game to try things.

“If there’s ever a game to experiment and look at alternative players or other opportunities, it was this one.”

Are the All Blacks’ World Cup ‘guarantees’ still guarantees?

New Zealanders will know more than he does, Youngs said. But some players “you assume would be guarantees for a World Cup” are now in question. “Obviously these question marks do come in when you get a result like that.”

“Now you’re looking: are they guarantees? And when’s their next opportunity?”

The group has been together a long time, so “they should be cohesive”. A strong leadership group, in his view, brings new players into the culture quickly.

He pointed to Richie Mo’unga, who in his prime was “the best, best, best 10 in the world”, as proof the talent is there.

What fascinated him was that, 14-nil down, New Zealand “weren’t able to figure that out”.

Will England’s attack hold up against the All Blacks?

England’s plan is more ambitious now, Youngs said. They move the ball with more tempo and look for wider edges. He has seen “a massive shift in the attitude and the ambition that England are playing with”, which he called “a real positive thing”.

England have played two teams that “allowed us to layer on that game plan more”, he said. That is why “this test is really important”.

He wants to know whether the attack is “as good as what we think we’re seeing at the moment”. The other outcome is that England come “highly unstuck”.

England v New Zealand kicks off at Allianz Stadium, Twickenham, at 2.10pm GMT on Saturday 21 November. If the plan stalls, Youngs has his own questions: “Are we going to stick with it? Are we going to change?”

READ MORE: Dave Rennie on the overlaps the All Blacks missed against Wales

How England Could Turn an All Blacks Upset Into a CrisisVideo · plays from YouTube
Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

A Wales player roaring with both fists clenched at the final whistle after the win over New Zealand
Next up

Ben Youngs: Wales win over All Blacks ‘not good for England’

England’s most capped player praises the Welsh crowd and defence, then explains why a New Zealand side with a point to prove worries him.

Wales · 3 min read

More on England

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?