Skip to content

Ben Youngs: Number 8 is where England lack a Kieran Read

Youngs says England’s back row carries with footwork rather than size, and names the gain line as the test against New Zealand.

England's Ben Earl carrying the ball at Twickenham
Photo: Inpho via Six Nations Rugby

The Aotearoa Rugby Pod asked England’s most capped player about Henry Pollock and Greg Fisilau. “We don’t have that traditional, big, ball-carrying Number 8. So England have to do it slightly different,” said Ben Youngs.

England host New Zealand at Allianz Stadium, Twickenham, at 2.10pm GMT on Saturday 21 November. The All Blacks arrive after Wales beat them 35-28, their first win over New Zealand since 1953.

Youngs measured England against Kieran Read: “Kieran Read was the all-court Number 8, right? He could lineout jump, he could offload, he could move, he could mix it when he needs to, he could jackal. England don’t really have that.”

Do England need a traditional ball-carrying Number 8 to beat the All Blacks? Tell us in the comments.

READ MORE: James Haskell on a hurt All Blacks side coming at England

Ben Youngs: Number 8 aside, England’s carriers are ‘not big guys’

Youngs looked at England’s back row and named Ben Earl, Ben Curry, Pollock and Fisilau. They are “actually not big guys”, he said.

They are dynamic, he said, and they create space “through footwork or trying to find soft shoulders”, which roughly means running at the weaker spots in a defence. But they are “not that traditional”.

Youngs said England are also playing a lock, a second-row jumper, at six. That is because they want to put the All Blacks’ lineout under pressure with three jumpers.

He called Fisilau “very dynamic for someone that I would say punches above his weight”.

What does a traditional ball-carrier look like to Youngs?

For the old style, he reached for Billy Vunipola. “Let’s say like a Billy Vunipola, who’s just a big lump, you know, can go down the middle and suck some defenders in.”

Who carries wide for England, Pollock or Fisilau?

Pollock and Fisilau can carry for England, Youngs said, but “not your traditional way”. They are more about footwork and wider channels, meaning the space towards the touchlines.

“I’d say Pollock would be the guy on the wider channels using his pace.”

It will be interesting to see “who’s in the middle, let’s say, and who’s holding the wider-channel edge”.

Can England win the gain line without a big carrier?

The gain line is the imaginary line across the pitch level with the tackle. A team that carries past it is going forward.

Youngs said the set piece, meaning scrums and lineouts, will matter. But then comes multi-phase play, which is attack that keeps the ball through several tackles in a row. There, he agreed with the host, the gain line is hugely important.

“So look, the gain line is everything this weekend. Can England physically match that?”

READ MORE: James Haskell on the All Blacks as England’s most important scalp

How England Could Turn an All Blacks Upset Into a CrisisVideo · plays from YouTube
Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

England fly-half Fin Smith in an England shirt
Next up

Ben Youngs: Fin Smith is ‘the guy moving forward’ for England

Youngs places Fin Smith between Marcus Smith and George Ford, says Ford still has a role, and asks New Zealand who should wear their 10.

England · 2 min read

More on England

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?