Skip to content

Ex-England scrum-half Ben Youngs calls Southern Hemisphere table ‘pretty dreadful’, can ‘only see a Springboks win’ in Dublin

Former England scrum-half Ben Youngs has called the Southern Hemisphere side of the Nations Championship “pretty dreadful” behind New Zealand and South Africa, and has backed the Springboks to beat Ireland in Dublin on Saturday.

Ben Youngs diving to score a try for England
ROME, ITALY - OCTOBER 31: Ben Youngs of England makes a break to score his sides second try during the 2020 Guinness Six Nations match between Italy and England at Olimpico Stadium on October 31, 2020 in Rome, Italy. Sporting stadiums around Italy remain under strict restrictions due to the Coronavirus Pandemic as Government social distancing laws prohibit fans inside venues resulting in games being played behind closed doors. (Photo by Emmanuele Ciancaglini/Quality Sport Images/Getty Images)

Former England scrum-half Ben Youngs has called the Southern Hemisphere side of the Nations Championship “pretty dreadful” behind New Zealand and South Africa, and has backed the Springboks to beat Ireland in Dublin on Saturday.

Youngs made the remarks on For The Love Of Rugby, the podcast he co-hosts with former England tighthead Dan Cole, in an episode released on Monday. In an earlier episode he said the All Blacks had been “almost arrogant” before losing to Wales.

Northern sides won five of the six Round 5 games, with Argentina’s 19-14 win over Italy the only exception. New Zealand lead the southern Nations Championship table on 22 points, ahead of South Africa (21), Argentina (11), Australia (nine), Japan (five) and Fiji (none).

READ MORE: Ben Youngs: Rassie Erasmus ‘got out-Rassied’ in Paris

‘Pretty dreadful’

New Zealand and South Africa both lost at the weekend, and without them, Youngs said, “the Southern Hemisphere table and group are pretty dreadful.”

“But I’m looking at it and I’m thinking, should we like offer up Spain or Portugal, Georgia?” the 2016 Grand Slam winner added.

He spared the other northern sides, though not Italy, who have one point.

Of New Zealand and South Africa, he said: “They are without doubt the top two … within the top three teams in the world.” He put France in the same bracket.

“So there’s your top three, but the rest they are all over the place. It is not good for rugby.”

Every game is played between the two tables. Northern sides have won 18 of the 30 so far, and the four southern teams below the top two have won four of 20.

‘That’s a massacre’

Japan’s defeat at Twickenham was his main example.

“Japan conceding 70 odd points … That is horrific. We’re talking about growing the game and all that. That does not grow the game. That’s a massacre.”

England won 78-15 at Allianz Stadium on Saturday 14 November, scoring 13 tries to two, after Japan lock Harry Hockings was shown a 20-minute red card in the first minute.

‘Only see a Springboks win’

Youngs then turned to Dublin.

“Ireland have to minimise entries from the Boks … That’s discipline, penalties,” he said. “You can’t give them easy entries. If you do, you’re getting mauled.

“… If you go to kick compete, Coley, and you knock it on, scrum, right? You then give away a penalty in the scrum. It’s then 60 metres upfield. Then they’re mauling you … like in a tumble dryer. This, you know, washing machine of just this horrible cycle. You can’t get out of it and the Boks can strangle you with that.

“Ireland’s attacking shape is going to be so important because they, they don’t have the physical size. So, they rely on that … short sort of connected shape, little passes, little movements …

“But I think the Boks’ defence is … still at another level, mate. It’s still at another level. I look at this and I can only see a Springboks win. I just, I can’t see Ireland being able to deal with that power.

“… Let’s be honest, if the game went on for another minute, two minutes, three minutes, I do think the Boks would have found a way against France. I do … And I’m not sure Ireland have the physical power to deal with the Boks.”

France beat South Africa 21-19 in Paris on Friday 13 November. The Springboks won 24-13 in Dublin last November, their first win there since 2012.

South Africa need one more point than New Zealand on Saturday to reach the final, and Ireland realistically need a win. Ireland v South Africa kicks off at 4.40pm GMT on Saturday 21 November at the Aviva Stadium, after England host New Zealand at 2.10pm.

Is The Southern Hemisphere Letting Rugby Down?Video · plays from YouTube

READ MORE: Rassie Erasmus: Dublin has not been ‘a happy hunting ground’

Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Asked which pack can live with the Springboks scrum, three former Springboks named a Scotland coach, dismissed England, and landed on two Wallabies.
Next up

Springboks Scrum Rankings From Three Of Their Own Legends. England Did Not Make The List.

Asked which pack can live with the Springboks scrum, three former Springboks named a Scotland coach, dismissed England, and landed on two Wallabies.

South Africa · 7 min read

More on England

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?