New Zealand podcast host Ross Karl has called England v New Zealand at Twickenham on Saturday “a 50/50 game”, and said home advantage may just put England ahead, breaking ranks with his own panel.
Karl hosts the Aotearoa Rugby Pod, published on Stuff’s YouTube channel, and gave his view in the closing segment of Monday’s episode. Earlier in the show, former All Blacks hooker James Parsons and former Crusaders scrum-half Bryn Hall had both answered “Yes” when he asked whether New Zealand would beat England.
The All Blacks lost 35-28 to Wales in Cardiff on 14 November, their first defeat to Wales since 1953. England beat Japan 78-15 at Twickenham the same day.
READ MORE: Bryn Hall: ‘If You’re England, You’re Licking Your Lips’
‘A 50/50 game’
Karl turned to Saturday’s Test at the end of the show.
“I think that it’s going to be pretty close … I think this is a 50/50 game,” he said.
He repeated the point moments later: “I think that this is a 50/50 game. Maybe home advantage just puts the English ahead slightly.”
‘They just absolutely blew it’
The host expects to see the All Blacks side that won at Murrayfield, not the one beaten in Cardiff.
“That’s difficult. And the reason that’s difficult is because I think you’ll see the team that played Scotland show up,” he explained.
“And that team that played Scotland obviously … did pretty well against the Wallabies, then did extremely well against the Scottish, you then have the motivational factor of the fact they just absolutely blew it. And the whole squad will take that on the chin, not just the team that played. So Dave Rennie is going to be coming out coming hard this week …
“… You know, there’s plenty for them to be motivated by. So, with that being said, and the fact that the English played against a team that was far below them, I’m just not sure that you can take this weekend into account at all.”
New Zealand beat Scotland 43-21 at Murrayfield on 7 November, after two wins over Australia in October. Japan were down to 14 men from the first minute to the 22nd at Twickenham, the weekend after England beat Australia 45-22.
Earlier in the episode, the panel had been asked to set the Cardiff result aside and judge England against the side that won at Murrayfield.
Twickenham record
England won 33-19 when the sides last met at Twickenham, in November 2025, their first home win over the All Blacks since 2012. The two Twickenham Tests before that ended 25-25 in 2022 and 24-22 to New Zealand in 2024.
New Zealand top the southern Nations Championship table on 22 points, one ahead of South Africa. England have 20 in the northern table, one behind France. Only the two table winners reach the final at Twickenham on 29 November.
England v New Zealand kicks off at 2.10pm GMT on Saturday 21 November at Allianz Stadium, Twickenham.

READ MORE: England v New Zealand preview: Eddie Jones says beaten All Blacks are ‘violent’









Comments
No one has weighed in yet.
Be the first - what did you make of it?