Skip to content
News

James Haskell and Mike Tindall back naming the XV an hour out

Payne wants the 23 named on Thursday and the XV an hour out. Tindall sees mind games everywhere, and Haskell has one condition.

Alex Payne (left), James Haskell (centre) and Mike Tindall (right) in a promotional photo
Photo: Radio Times (promotional image)

James Haskell has no problem with Rassie Erasmus swapping his front row an hour before kick-off in Paris. “I just think if you can manipulate rules and get away with it, why not?” the former England flanker said on The Good, The Bad & The Rugby. He would even drop rugby’s laws into ChatGPT to find more ways to bend them.

Host Alex Payne then went further: should rugby name the starting XV an hour before kick-off, like football? “Mind games everywhere,” said Mike Tindall. “Journos would hate it, wouldn’t they?” Both he and Haskell liked the idea.

Would you be happy to wait until an hour before kick-off to see your team’s starting XV? Tell us in the comments.

Rassie Erasmus broke no rule in Paris

The Springboks started their three named replacement front-rowers against France on 13 November, a switch confirmed about an hour before kick-off. Erasmus said the call was made on the Thursday. France won 21-19, and he later admitted the front-row switch had “a little bit of an eye on the World Cup”.

Payne said the Boks were within the rules. “He hasn’t done anything wrong,” he said. “What he has done is check the T’s and C’s.”

James Haskell would ask ChatGPT for more loopholes

Haskell’s answer was to find more of them. “Let’s get all the laws, drop them into chat… let’s find 10 ways that I could bend these rules,” he said, meaning ChatGPT.

Payne’s idea: the 23 on Thursday, the XV an hour out

Payne pointed to football. Starting line-ups there are announced an hour before kick-off, he said, and “people tune in to see who’s going to play.”

“If you named your 23 on a Thursday, but you didn’t have to commit to your starting 15 until an hour before kickoff…” he said.

With teams so evenly matched now, he asked, would they like coaches “having to make people think”? Or should the team stay fixed on a Thursday, so fans can argue over the head-to-heads?

Tindall says it would be mind games everywhere

Tindall jumped in before Payne had even finished the question, and he soon turned to the press box.

He remembered a Heineken Cup game involving Pontypridd, where rain on the morning of the match changed a team’s selection. “So it does happen,” he said.

Haskell had one condition. He separated “what you owe the public versus what you do behind closed doors”, and was relaxed about late switches “as long as the players know.”

Would Tindall go even further than Payne?

He would. “Ultimately I think it’s fine to do and got no issues with it. I think you can lean right into it,” Tindall said.

His bigger idea is to cap the number of replacements a team can use but put the whole squad on the bench. “That way you can actually make tactical changes,” he said.

Haskell called it “too creative”. “That will take precisely 200 years to come to fruition in rugby.”

Is rugby already halfway there?

Maybe. Aotearoa Rugby Pod host Ross Karl read out the rules on air. World Rugby’s regulation asks for the starting XV and replacements 48 hours out, he said, but the Nations Championship only needs the final squad an hour before kick-off. Karl called late changes “a little bit of a farce”.

Erasmus was banned for six matches over his “match-fixing” remarks on Tuesday, so he is due to miss Saturday’s Test against Ireland at the Aviva Stadium. SA Rugby has asked for a full hearing. Before the ban, he told Ireland he might switch his team late again.

So would an hour-out XV make rugby better, or does it just reward the coach who bluffs best?

Rassie Erasmus Banned After “Match Fixing” CommentsVideo · plays from YouTube

Video: The Good, The Bad & The Rugby, “Rassie Erasmus Banned After ‘Match Fixing’ Comments”.

Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?