Skip to content

Schalk Burger: Boks told knee drops were ‘simultaneous’

A coach on the Boks Unpacked panel asks how fans can follow the knee-drop law when coaches can't, as Erasmus sits out Dublin.

France players celebrate their 21-19 win over South Africa at the Stade de France
Photo: Nations Championship broadcast

Schalk Burger says Siya Kolisi and Pieter-Steph du Toit asked about France’s knee drops in Paris and kept hearing one word back: “simultaneous”. The former Springboks flanker calls that answer “definitely, absolutely not”.

“Every time it’s a knee drop, it’s simultaneous, 17 times in a row,” he said on SuperSport’s Boks Unpacked on Friday.

Were those knee drops simultaneous, or did the officials get it wrong? Tell us in the comments.

Rassie BANNED! Is World Rugby Against the Springboks?Video · plays from YouTube

What did Siya Kolisi and Pieter-Steph du Toit ask?

Burger says two senior Springboks raised the knee drops with the referee during the 21-19 defeat to France.

“There was also a clear communication from first [Siya] and then [Pieter-Steph du Toit],” he said.

He expected an “I’ll have a look” or a TMO check. Instead, he says, the referee gave his own view.

The reply, as Burger tells it: “For the knee drops it is, no, in my point of view it’s simultaneous.” His verdict: “Definitely, absolutely not.”

A knee drop is when the tackler drops onto his knees into the ball carrier’s legs. Burger admits they went unpunished in his day.

“Don’t get me wrong, back in the day when we were playing, last season, knee drops weren’t [refereed], but this is the new directive,” he said.

Why knee drops frustrate coaches

For Burger, this is where coaches’ main frustration comes from.

“You coach your players specifically around that tackle technique not to do it,” he said.

“…and then you play against a team who [does] knee drops and nothing gets done about it, and the referee and his panel then say it’s simultaneous.”

Burger’s “17 times in a row” is the same number Rassie Erasmus used after the match.

Not everyone counts 17. Brian O’Driscoll went back through the tape and found five in the first half, all from France flanker François Cros, and called Erasmus’s figure “fanciful”.

“How can a fan understand it?”

Burger’s fellow panellist, a coach, said the Springboks did the right thing by asking in the moment.

“We asked the question politely to the referee and showed a lot of respect,” he said. “We flagged it, which I think is good leadership.”

For him, the problem is a lack of clarity.

“If coaches who live in this game every day can’t understand it, how can a fan understand it?”

Why is Erasmus missing Dublin?

The panel summed up Erasmus’s point: if the tackles were on the TMO’s screens, why were they not flagged? World Rugby banned him for six matches over his “match-fixing” remarks, so he misses Saturday’s Test against Ireland in Dublin.

Ireland v South Africa kicks off at the Aviva Stadium at 4.40pm GMT on Saturday 21 November. The first knee drop in Dublin will show whether anything has changed.

READ MORE: Schalk Burger: World Rugby ‘needs to grow a pair’

Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Siya Kolisi celebrates in a Springboks jersey
Next up

Siya Kolisi took the blame in Paris. Did it swing the cards?

Five cards in Paris, two to South Africa. Steven Kitshoff says it could have been three and none, and credits Siya Kolisi's talks with the referee.

France · 3 min read

More on South Africa

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?