Nigel Owens has explained why Billy Pollard‘s maul try was taken off the Wallabies at Murrayfield, in a game they lost 15-12 to Scotland.
The Wallabies hooker went over from a lineout drive on 35 minutes, but the TMO ruled it out for obstruction. On World Rugby’s Whistle Watch show, Owens said the Wallabies had blocked Scotland from the one man they were allowed to tackle.
“You can sort of you know be partly shielding them but you can’t be directly preventing any access at all,” the former Test referee said.
Was it the right call, or should Australia have had those five points? Tell us in the comments.

Why was Billy Pollard’s maul try ruled out?
Owens said the attacking side “just closes the gate”. The Wallabies’ catcher was lifted, turned as he came down, and a team-mate then stepped directly in front of him.
“They can’t take anybody down in the formation of that [maul] from the [lineout]. They can only sack the ball carrier,” he said. “So obviously if they can’t get at the ball carrier then legally they can’t sack that ball.”
He said it is a common move and hard to spot live, because everyone closes in at once. “It’s very difficult for the officials in the field to pick it up really,” he said. “What they need to do is they have to allow access for the defence to get hold of the ball carrier.”
Owens says the maul is now too hard to stop
Asked why defences do not just sack mauls five metres out, Owens said the two support jumpers make it very hard once a drive is set. Defenders cannot take them down either.
Then came his verdict on the law itself. “[The maul] is one law I would like them to look at a bit again I think because basically now you get [the maul] within 8 m of the try line you’re going to score,” he said.
He said a recent law change on defenders rejoining had pushed the balance further. “I think the huge onus now was moved to the attack and you’re seeing a lot of [maul] tries, penalty tries,” he said.
Australia lost by three points, and the maul try that was ruled out would have been worth at least five.
The Darcy Graham call went Australia’s way
Not every call at Murrayfield hurt the Wallabies. On 24 minutes Kyle Steyn kneed a cross-field grubber on and Darcy Graham touched down. The TMO ruled it out.
Owens said a player in touch can still play the ball if the ball itself is in the field of play. “The law allows you to kick that ball or knock it back as long as you don’t try to gather it even though you are in touch,” he said.
The problem was where the ball was. When the replays were checked, both Steyn and the ball were in touch, so the try was “quite rightly” chalked off.
What it means for the Wallabies against Wales
Australia go to Cardiff on Saturday (8.10pm GMT, 7.10am Sunday in Sydney) needing a win to avoid their first Home Unions whitewash since 1958. Wales are fresh from beating the All Blacks, and Les Kiss has moved Fraser McReight to the bench.
If the Wallabies get a lineout drive close to the Welsh line, Owens’ warning applies to them: give the defence a path to the ball carrier.
READ MORE: Wallabies player ratings vs Scotland: McReight’s 31 tackles not enough









Comments
No one has weighed in yet.
Be the first - what did you make of it?