Sam Prendergast will fight his hip-drop citing at an independent disciplinary hearing in Dublin at 8pm tonight, with his place against the Springboks on Saturday riding on the outcome.
It is the first citing for a hip-drop tackle since World Rugby outlawed it on 1 November, and Springboks coach Rassie Erasmus has already called it. “My gut feeling is he’ll play on Saturday,” he said on Monday.
Should Prendergast be banned for the Springboks game? Tell us in the comments.
What is Prendergast cited for?
The Ireland fly-half brought down Fiji captain Peceli Yato in the 23rd minute of Ireland’s 43-15 win on Saturday. Yato went on to score a try but was forced off injured soon after.
The tackle went unpunished on the day. The citing commissioner then cited Prendergast, which means the commissioner believes it should have been a red card.
Under the Nations Championship’s fast-track process, Prendergast could have accepted the charge and taken a ban without a hearing. Ireland have chosen to contest it.
How will Ireland argue it?
World Rugby’s guidance says a hip-drop tackle with “minimal contact on lower limbs” is a penalty. With “higher level contact with lower limbs”, yellow and red cards come into play.
The panel weighs the level of control, whether the tackler dives or leaves the ground, whether his hips drop onto a ball carrier moving at speed, any sudden swing or drop, and how hard he lands on the leg.
Prendergast will argue that his tackle met “potentially two and absolutely no more than three” of those criteria, The Irish Times reports, short of the red-card threshold.
The panel is chaired by England’s Mike Hamlin, a retired lawyer and deputy district judge. He sits with Australian Wayne Erickson, who refereed at two World Cups, and Becky Essex, who won 57 caps for England.
There is one precedent. Australia’s Angus Bell got the first yellow card for a hip drop, on England’s Immanuel Feyi-Waboso, and the foul play review officer decided it should not be upgraded to red.
Rassie Erasmus is banned, and Ireland are not happy
Erasmus said on Monday that Prendergast should have been sent off. “We all thought it’s an immediate red card,” he said, before predicting a “technicality” would let him play.
The Irish Times suggested Ireland’s management would see those remarks as prejudicial to the hearing.
Erasmus has since been banned for six matches by World Rugby over his comments about the match officials in the defeat to France, which rules him out of the rest of the Nations Championship.
Who plays 10 if Prendergast is banned?
Ciarán Frawley is the leading candidate to start against South Africa, with Ulster’s Jamie Benson in line for the bench. A decision is expected tonight, before Andy Farrell names his team on Thursday.
Ireland v South Africa kicks off at the Aviva Stadium at 4.40pm GMT on Saturday 21 November. Jake White has already picked out the Springboks scrum call Ireland should fear.
Ban or no ban? Have your say in the comments. We will update this story when the panel’s decision is announced.




Comments
No one has weighed in yet.
Be the first - what did you make of it?