Skip to content

Schalk Burger: ref ‘bailed out the contest’ as Boks scrum was ‘one-way traffic’

Springboks great Schalk Burger has said referee Andrea Piardi “bailed out the contest” at scrum time in Paris, where the Springboks scrum was “one-way traffic” before France held on to win 21-19.

Schalk Burger at a Springboks press conference

Springboks great Schalk Burger has said referee Andrea Piardi “bailed out the contest” at scrum time in Paris, where the Springboks scrum was “one-way traffic” before France held on to win 21-19.

Burger made the comments on SuperSport’s The Verdict, alongside host and former Springboks captain Jean de Villiers and fellow panellist and coach Footy, in an episode released on Tuesday.

France beat the Springboks 21-19 at the Stade de France on Friday 13 November, their first win over South Africa in Paris since 2005. The Springboks won every scrum and lost by two points after Jasper Wiese was shown a red card in the 43rd minute.

READ MORE: Springboks player ratings vs France: an 8 for Pieter-Steph du Toit

Schalk Burger: ‘One-way traffic’

De Villiers put it to the former Springboks flanker: “Did the referee completely lose control of the scrums?”

“No. He just bailed out the contest,” Burger said. “You can’t have a 5m scrum. Scrum’s been one-way traffic. … Put the French on a team warning. Then after that, give a penalty. Say, ‘Okay, that’s not a team warning, because he can’t figure out the individual.’ Yes, it was. It was number 18 and it was the tighthead.

“And then after that, the same picture happens again. And then you say, ‘No, but now we got to play away, because it’s now not a penalty the fifth time.’ I don’t quite get it.

“But then when it doesn’t matter, the next following scrum, you give a yellow card … and then, you know, with a kickable penalty in the 78th minute, then you go, ‘Okay, now it’s changed again. Now it’s play away.’”

Replacement prop Régis Montagne was sin-binned in the 68th minute after a run of Springboks scrum penalties. He conceded four penalties, more than any other player, and nine of France’s 14 came from their props.

France’s scrum success rate was 85.7%, against 100% for the Springboks. Malcolm Marx crashed over three minutes after the card to make it 21-19, and France held on through the last nine minutes.

‘Our strategy is scrum’

De Villiers then asked Footy whether the scrum was one area where it was “so easy just to bail out and not make a decision”, with “no accountability”.

“Yeah, I think it’s a hard one, you know, to make a call, you know, at that moment, but it’s especially in France with that crowd. I agree with [Burger], that had to be the call. He had put them on a warning,” Footy said.

“Our strategy is, we’re going to scrum you, and we didn’t get the reward. When he said team warning, of course, we’re going to go for scrum … The reality is it’s our weapon. It didn’t come to fruit.”

Springboks head coach Rassie Erasmus said after the match that he was not blaming Piardi. He put the mistake on his own side, saying it was “just human not to keep on penalising if they’ve already got a card or two for that”.

The late yellow card

The panel came back to the scrums when they went through the clips later in the show, pointing to one sequence that came “after multiple, multiple scrums, multiple penalties”.

When the clips reached the scrum that did bring a yellow card, one of the panel asked: “So why is this a straight penalty, yellow card, and not the one 5m from it? The only reason is you bail out of the contest.”

The Springboks play Ireland in Dublin on Saturday 21 November, with kick-off at 4.40pm GMT.

Did the Referee Cost the Springboks Victory Against France? | The VerdictVideo · plays from YouTube

READ MORE: Springboks great Schalk Burger says Ireland ‘got bullied’ in Dublin, their pack ‘put in the sausage machine’

Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?