Skip to content
News

Shane Horgan: Rassie Erasmus a ‘genius’ with a ‘Trumpian’ streak

The former Ireland wing on why he says the Springboks cannot play the underdog, and why the term “match-fixing” crossed a line for him.

Shane Horgan, the former Ireland wing, seated in an armchair in front of a brick wall
Photo: Business Post (interview portrait; photographer not stated)

Shane Horgan calls Rassie Erasmus “a rugby genius”. Then he calls part of his behaviour “Trumpian”, and the former Ireland wing does not mean it kindly.

He said it on The Good, The Bad & The Rugby after World Rugby banned Erasmus for six Tests over his “match-fixing” question about a TMO, the video referee. Of Erasmus’s conduct, Horgan said: “quite insidious what he’s done over a period of time”.

Rugby genius, or has Rassie gone too far this time? Tell us in the comments.

The ‘Trumpian’ comparison started with a newspaper headline

Host Alex Payne read out what he said was a Telegraph headline, which had Erasmus “becoming the Donald Trump of rugby”. Payne said he thought it ran in the Telegraph, and we could not find the piece. Horgan’s own word is “Trumpian”.

His answer began with praise: “Rassie is one of them,” he said. Then came the caveat. “But I would totally agree there is something Trumpian about some of his behaviours.”

The problem, he said, was how Erasmus explains a defeat. “I think it’s depressing to say that if we lose it’s because something else has happened. That’s what he does.” He made it political. A leader who loses an election says “it’s because it’s fixed”.

Horgan says Erasmus blames World Rugby when the Springboks lose

“So Rassie has got to this position that if we lose, it’s somebody else’s fault,” Horgan said. “And generally it’s World Rugby’s fault because somehow they’re against us.”

The Springboks’ record answers that. Erasmus was head coach when South Africa won the 2019 World Cup. He was director of rugby when they won the 2023 one. In between, they beat the British & Irish Lions in 2021.

Then he turned the claim round. “By the way, if they are, it’s the worst conspiracy theory of all time, them having won two World Cups and the Lions series,” Horgan said.

Horgan says Rassie Erasmus’s Springboks cannot be underdogs

Horgan thinks the underdog story is deliberate. “You see it creates that siege mentality,” he said. He asked how the Springboks can be underdogs “with what all they’ve achieved”.

He allowed that Erasmus may have “some legitimate issues”, and that “he’s not direct”. He was still clear about the method. “He’s using the term match-fixing… in a press conference… post a game. You just don’t do that, Alex… if you do it, expect consequences.”

Erasmus says it was not an accusation, and SA Rugby wants a hearing

At Monday’s press conference, Erasmus asked whether it is match-fixing if a TMO sees foul play and decides not to act. World Rugby’s panel treated it as an attack on the officials’ integrity. France had beaten his side 21-19 in Paris on 13 November. Read that match story here.

SA Rugby has asked for a full misconduct hearing, and the Springboks said so in a statement on Tuesday evening. No date has been set. The ban stands for now.

Horgan’s verdict on the damage was short. “He can only have himself to blame, and I do think it’s extremely damaging to rugby to undermine it in this way.”

Ireland face the Springboks at the Aviva Stadium on Saturday without him, because Erasmus cannot enter the stadium. This is his third ban over referees. Every Rassie Erasmus ban is listed here.

READ MORE: Dublin has not been a “happy hunting ground” for Rassie Erasmus

Watch: Shane Horgan on Rassie Erasmus on The Good, The Bad & The Rugby (from 2:13).

Rassie Erasmus Banned After “Match Fixing” CommentsVideo · plays from YouTube
Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?