Skip to content

France v Argentina: Jalibert set for 10, Dupont back at 9

Laurent Sempéré answers the fitness question, and the table maths shows why France may need four tries against the Pumas.

Matthieu Jalibert applauds the crowd in a blue France shirt after a Test under the stadium lights
Photo: Getty Images (via RugbyPass)

Matthieu Jalibert is set to start at fly-half in France v Argentina on Saturday, nine weeks after his last game. French outlets report that he wore a starter’s bib next to Antoine Dupont at Marcoussis on Tuesday. That would send the captain back to scrum-half after his first Test start at 10, in the win over the Springboks.

Too soon? Assistant coach Laurent Sempéré says no: “If Matthieu is here, it’s because medically, everything has been checked.” France top the Northern table by one point going into the last round. If England beat the All Blacks with a bonus point, a France win without one may not be enough to reach the final.

Would you start Jalibert straight back in at 10, or keep the half-backs who beat the Springboks? Tell us in the comments.

France played the Springboks without a specialist fly-half

Romain Ntamack hurt his shoulder against Fiji in Lyon, and Thomas Ramos and Antoine Hastoy were also unavailable, according to Planète Rugby. So Fabien Galthié moved Dupont to 10 and started Maxime Lucu at 9 for the Springboks.

It worked. France led 21-7 at half-time and held on to win 21-19 at the Stade de France last Friday. It was their first win over South Africa in Paris since 2005. We gave Dupont a 9.5 in our France player ratings.

Lucu, Jalibert’s club team-mate at Bordeaux-Bègles, drops to the bench in Media365’s likely side.

Jalibert hinted at this on Springboks night

Jalibert has not played since 20 September. He hurt his right quadriceps, then broke down again in mid-October.

Before kick-off against South Africa, he told TF1 he was close.

“I’ve worked pretty well, I’m on the road back, and why not a nice surprise before the end.”

Two days later he was named in the 42-man squad for Argentina. He is 28 and has 42 caps.

Is it a risk to start him against the Pumas?

Planète Rugby reports that Jalibert went through the return-to-play protocol at his club, and the France medical staff then signed it off.

On RMC’s Super Moscato Show on Tuesday, Vincent Moscato saw no debate at all: Jalibert should start.

France v Argentina: a likely XV with a whole new back row

Media365 published its likely XV after Tuesday’s session at Marcoussis. Planète Rugby says the forwards were not on show in the ten minutes open to the press, so the pack is the less certain half. Galthié names the official team on Thursday 19 November.

Backs: Théo Attissogbe; Grégoire Arfeuil (or Aaron Grandidier Nkanang), Kalvin Gourgues, Yoram Moefana, Louis Bielle-Biarrey; Jalibert, Dupont (captain).

Forwards: Anthony Jelonch, Charles Ollivon, Esteban Capilla; Mickaël Guillard, Florian Verhaeghe; Sipili Falatea, Peato Mauvaka, Jean-Baptiste Gros.

Grandidier Nkanang, who scored France’s first try against the Springboks, was rested on Tuesday. Planète Rugby and Media365 both have Capilla in line for his first Test start. That would mean a whole new back row from the one that beat South Africa.

Why a France win might not be enough

France are on 21 points. England and Ireland have 20 each. Only the top team plays the Southern winner in the final at Twickenham on Sunday 29 November, as our Nations Championship table explainer sets out.

A bonus-point win settles it. That takes France to 26, and nobody else can pass 25.

A win without the bonus point leaves the door open. If England beat New Zealand with four tries, both sides would finish on 25 points with five wins. Next comes points difference, and England start 54 ahead (+134 to +80). Ireland start 23 behind France, at +57.

France will know the sum before they run out. England v New Zealand kicks off at 14:10 GMT, and Ireland host the Springboks in Dublin at 16:40 GMT. France v Argentina kicks off at 21:10 in Paris (20:10 UK), with both of those games finished.

“Nothing is over,” says Galthié

Galthié was already warning his players after the Springboks win. “Nothing is over,” he said that night.

He also knows this opponent. “We’re hosting Argentina, and Argentina are a great team. We’ve often suffered enormously. We know them well, half of them play in France.”

Argentina come in third in the Southern table after beating Italy 19-14 in Genoa. Charles Ollivon has done the counting: “We need two wins.”

If Jalibert starts, Saturday is the first of them. Read our England v New Zealand preview for the game that sets France’s target.

All quotes are translated from French.

Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Siya Kolisi carries the ball into a French tackle with Pieter-Steph du Toit in support
Next up

Kevin Putt: Springboks ‘Were Terrible’ Against France In Paris

Kevin Putt played scrum-half for the Springboks, and he says they "were terrible on the day" in Paris. Now his family in Ireland "see a little bit of a weakness"…

South Africa · 3 min read

More on France

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?