Nick Mallett says Rassie Erasmus’s late front-row switch in Paris “didn’t work”, and the damage went beyond the scrum. With no early dominance, he said, “we started playing like France”, and the Springboks are “not as good as them at that”.
The former Springboks coach also called Andrea Piardi’s late “play away” scrum call “a copout”. He was speaking on Talking Boks the morning after France won 21-19 at the Stade de France on Friday 13 November.
Should the Springboks stop trying to match France and New Zealand at their own game? Tell us in the comments.
Erasmus swapped his whole front row just before kick-off
Erasmus named Ox Nché, Malcolm Marx and Wilco Louw to start on Monday 9 November. Shortly before kick-off on Friday he started Gerhard Steenekamp, Jan-Hendrik Wessels and Thomas du Toit instead. The original three came on after 35 minutes.
Erasmus said afterwards it was “mainly with testing that combination with the Rugby World Cup next year in mind”, RugbyPass reported.
Mallett, who coached the Springboks from 1997 to 2000, was not convinced. “I’m not sure quite why we did it,” he said, “but … for me it didn’t work because we didn’t get any scrum dominance and … we started playing like France.”
France were 14-0 up after 23 minutes and 21-7 ahead at half-time. Wessels, one of the three late picks, scored South Africa’s only first-half try.
Mallett would always start Marx, the ‘best hooker in the world’
Asked what was in Erasmus’s mind, Mallett started with a warning. “Well, no one gets into Rassie’s mind.”
His guess was that Erasmus wanted a quicker pack to chase down France’s offloads and width. “I think he wanted to match mobility with mobility, put it that way,” he said, “but unfortunately it didn’t work.”
He would have done it the other way round. Start the strongest scrum, give France bad ball and win penalties. Bring the quick men on for the last 20 minutes. He called Nché “the best loose head” in the world and said Marx “is the best hooker in the world”.
‘We’re not as good as them at that’
In September, after Baltimore, Mallett said movement rugby will not beat the Springboks. He said South Africa cannot beat New Zealand or France by just playing at pace either. “That’s not going to work.”
“I think it was a case of not imposing our game on France, rather trying to match France’s game or match New Zealand’s game. We’re not as good as them at that,” he said.
“And … until such time as we stick to what we’re good at … we will always end up by struggling I think.”
The writer Gavin Rich pushed back on the same show. He said the Springboks “sometimes need to fight fire with fire” and pointed to the 2023 World Cup quarter-final against France. To him, the night showed why attack coach Tony Brown is there.
Mallett agreed “we want a varied game”, but gave France the credit for boxing South Africa in. “They did their homework and they did make us look like a team that could only score from a driving maul or a scrum penalty.”
Why Nick Mallett called the late scrum call a ‘copout’
Mallett thought Piardi got most calls right on the night, the cards included. The exception came in the last 10 minutes. France had been warned about collapsing, and replacement prop Régis Montagne was sin-binned in the 68th minute. Marx’s try three minutes later cut the gap to 21-19.
Then another scrum went down and Piardi told both sides to play on. Mallett said a dominant scrum has no reason to collapse. “So, it can only go down because they’re under pressure. And … I thought that was a copout.”
A penalty there, he said, could have meant a kick at goal or a lineout in the corner.
Erasmus did not blame the referee. He said afterwards that “maybe the call should have been let’s kick for touch and maul it rather”. Jake White has already warned Ireland about that scrum call. Schalk Burger went further on SuperSport, saying Piardi “bailed out the contest”.
Erasmus has gone back to Nché, Marx and Louw, but won’t be in Dublin
The show was recorded before two bigger stories broke. On Monday Erasmus named Nché, Marx and Louw to start against Ireland, with the Paris trio on the bench.
“We let ourselves and the country down, and we are determined to fix the mistakes that cost us,” he said, as reported by TimesLIVE.
On Tuesday World Rugby banned Erasmus for six matches over his “match-fixing” remark about the TMO (the video referee). He misses Dublin, and SA Rugby has asked for a full misconduct hearing.
Mallett knows the mood after one defeat. The Springboks won 17 Tests in a row in 1997-98, 16 of them under Mallett, before England beat them at Twickenham in December 1998. “It’s a sense of relief when you win as opposed to happiness and joy,” he said of that run.
“We know what we did wrong against France and we’ve got to be better the next weekend,” he said.
Ireland v South Africa kicks off at the Aviva Stadium at 4.40pm GMT (6.40pm SA time) on Saturday 21 November. Matfield wants the 9, 10 and 12 to step up.





Comments
No one has weighed in yet.
Be the first - what did you make of it?