Skip to content

All Blacks v England ‘Season Defining’, Says John Kirwan

John Kirwan says the All Blacks 'lost the passion battle' in Cardiff, and that Saturday's Test is 'season defining' for the team.

All Blacks players walk off the field dejected after a defeat
Photo: Lefty Shivambu / Gallo Images

Sir John Kirwan says All Blacks v England on Saturday is “season defining”, with a place in the Nations Championship final on the line.

Asked on the Rugby Rivals podcast whether the Test decides Dave Rennie’s season, he said: “Yeah, totally. It’s season defining for the team.”

“It was a mental lapse last weekend, and this team is now under pressure to perform at their best and win a Test match, and it’ll be tight.”

Can the All Blacks bounce back at Twickenham? Tell us in the comments.

‘We lost the passion battle’

Wales won 35-28 in Cardiff, their first win over New Zealand since 1953.

France beat South Africa 21-19 the night before. Kirwan said the two losses felt very different.

“You guys lost in a tight encounter,” he told Victor Matfield. “We lost the passion battle, and that would be the hardest thing for the All Blacks to swallow.”

He said the All Blacks call their work “bone-deep preparation”: watching 100 lineouts and going back six games. “But you cannot leave out the passion piece.”

Rennie has already admitted his side were out-passioned.

Why did the All Blacks leave men “unmarked out wide”?

Kirwan used a phrase from Gilbert Enoka, the All Blacks’ long-time mental skills manager. A player with a “red head” panics and stops seeing what is in front of him.

“Under pressure we started getting what Gilbert Enoka would say, the red head. There was times where there was five or six guys unmarked out wide. All they had to do was call and go.”

Rennie’s own review found “probably 10” times his players didn’t “do the obvious”.

All Blacks v England: Tupaea out, Jordan a doubt

Kirwan said Rennie had “really put his faith” in centre Quinn Tupaea. Tupaea fractured his thumb in Cardiff and is out for the rest of the Nations Championship.

Lock Jamie Hannah is out too, with a fractured shoulder blade.

Then there is Will Jordan, “that magical X-factor player that can score a try out of nothing”.

Jordan has a small hamstring tear and could still play. Kirwan is not so sure he will make it.

Kirwan: England will “tactically kick you into the corners”

The English media are often hard on their own side, Kirwan said, but he thinks England have found a style that suits them.

He sees hard-working forwards, big back-rowers who carry hard, and a backline that will “tactically kick you into the corners and put you under pressure”.

Matfield, a Springboks great, still backs New Zealand. “I’m backing New Zealand to win that game,” he said.

England v New Zealand kicks off at 2.10pm GMT on Saturday 21 November. A bonus-point win would put the All Blacks in the Nations Championship final.

READ MORE: Why Kirwan thinks Mo’unga is ‘probably not’ in a Test spot after Japan

Sir John Kirwan and Victor Matfield were speaking on the Rugby Rivals podcast, published on 17 November 2026. Watch the full discussion.

All Blacks & Springboks Beaten! JK & Victor React to Rugby’s Wildest WeekendVideo · plays from YouTube
Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

England players face the All Blacks haka at Allianz Stadium Twickenham in November 2025.
Next up

Kevin Putt: All Blacks Depth ‘Not Good Enough’ For 10 Changes

Kevin Putt's fix for Twickenham is simple: "We reselect. We go with our best team."

New Zealand · 3 min read

More on New Zealand

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?