Skip to content

Andy Farrell: Rugby refereeing ‘never going to be perfect’

Days after Rassie Erasmus got a six-match ban, the Ireland coach backed Christophe Ridley and explained why he keeps his views on officials to himself.

Ireland head coach Andy Farrell on the touchline at the Aviva Stadium
Photo: The Sun Ireland

Ireland head coach Andy Farrell has refused to join the attack on match officials, saying rugby is one of the hardest sports in the world to referee and coaches have a duty to “protect the game”. He spoke in Dublin before Saturday’s Nations Championship Test against South Africa, days after Springboks boss Rassie Erasmus was banned for six matches over his own comments about referees.

He did not mention Erasmus by name, but the timing made the point for him.

Is Farrell right to stay quiet on referees, or should coaches speak up when calls go wrong? Tell us in the comments.

Why Andy Farrell says rugby is harder to referee than football

Farrell was asked, according to BBC Sport, why he stays so tight-lipped about officials. His answer started with football.

“You’re talking about football, that’s easy to referee. Rugby’s not,” he said. “It’s complex, you know. There’s so many moving parts. I think it’s one of the hardest sports in the world to referee so it’s never going to be perfect.”

He said coaches also had a job to do. “We need to make sure that we protect the game in general as far as we want people to referee our sport coming through as well.”

Erasmus went the other way, and it cost him

Erasmus has taken the opposite road. He was handed a six-match ban this week, the third time he has been sanctioned for criticising officials.

During a 35-minute news conference in Dublin, the two-time World Cup winner claimed officials missed 17 hip-drop or knee-drop tackles in South Africa’s defeat to France in Paris last week. He went further, suggesting that a TMO who saw an offence and chose not to act raised the question of match-fixing.

Brian O’Driscoll later went through the tape and counted five in the first half. Hip-drop and knee-drop tackles were outlawed before the November internationals began.

Erasmus had also predicted that Ireland fly-half Sam Prendergast would be available, and he was right. Prendergast was cited for a hip-drop tackle against Fiji but cleared after a panel ruled it was not a red-card offence.

Does Christophe Ridley face extra pressure in Dublin?

Not according to Farrell. England’s Christophe Ridley takes charge of Ireland v South Africa, and Farrell backed him in strong terms.

“Christophe is a top-class referee,” he said, describing him as level-headed and very experienced with both sides. “I think he’s the perfect guy to take this on.”

What Ireland learned from France’s win over the Boks

Ireland have a score to settle. They lost 24-13 to South Africa in Dublin last year in a game where they were shown five cards and finished the first half with 12 players on the pitch.

Ireland have beaten Argentina and Fiji this month, while France edged the Springboks at the Stade de France. Asked what Les Bleus had shown him, Farrell kept it simple: take your chances.

“If you get a few chances, that’s when you need to put the points on the board because they don’t give you many, but France were excellent in that regard,” he said. He added that Ireland “still had a few opportunities that we didn’t take”.

Ireland face South Africa at the Aviva Stadium on Saturday 21 November, kick-off 4.40pm GMT. Will Ridley get through the afternoon without a word of complaint from either coach? Tell us below.

READ MORE: Andy Farrell’s ‘hair done’ reply to Rassie Erasmus jibe

Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Siya Kolisi celebrates in a Springboks jersey
Next up

Siya Kolisi: Springboks are ‘representing every single person in South Africa’

The Springboks captain explains why a two-point defeat to France hurt so much, as South Africa prepare to face Ireland in Dublin.

Ireland · 2 min read

More on Ireland

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?