Skip to content

Ben Youngs: maul interpretation has teams skipping penalty goals

Youngs says Wales had a free swing, teams now contest the five-metre line and he wonders if World Rugby will act.

Jamie George breaks away from an England maul against Australia at Twickenham
Photo: Getty Images via The Telegraph

Should England kick at goal or kick for the corner against the All Blacks on Saturday? Ben Youngs has an instinct. “My instincts say this weekend you take your three. You respect New Zealand hugely,” he told the Aotearoa Rugby Pod.

Taking the three means kicking the penalty for three points. The other option is kicking to the corner for a lineout, then driving a maul: the pack bound together, pushing forward with the ball. Youngs says the new maul interpretation has teams choosing the corner more often.

Would you turn down three at Twickenham? Tell us in the comments.

READ MORE: Biggar says the Wales dam will burst on possession

How has the maul interpretation changed the game?

Youngs said it is “very evident” across the last couple of weekends.

Defenders used to stop a maul by coming in from the side. “Beforehand you could sort of almost swim, they call it swimming up the side of the maul… you can’t do that now.”

“So the maul is becoming such a weapon that teams are refusing to take three and going to the corner,” he said. “They feel like, as long as they catch it, they can win it.”

Defences are adapting too. “Teams are now competing on the 5-metre line,” he said, meaning they jump to contest the throw. He called France’s corner kick against the Springboks, about the 44th minute, he thought, “a massive moment”. Pieter-Steph du Toit “goes up, which is risky, but goes up and steals it”.

Was Wales’ corner kicking a free swing?

A host said Scotland had also had success against the All Blacks with the driving maul. Youngs added a reason for the Welsh corner kicks. “It was a free swing for Wales. There was absolutely no expectation and nothing on the line.”

Wales beat New Zealand 35-28 at the Principality Stadium on Saturday 14 November.

Youngs wonders what World Rugby will do next. “I am intrigued whether these mauls continue, whether World Rugby looks at it again,” he said. He floated stopping backs from hitting the maul.

Would England kick for the corner against the All Blacks?

A host asked whether this England side, with its new mindset, is a kick-to-the-corner team. Youngs then put the question to himself. “Will England turn it down against the All Blacks at the weekend? I’ll be surprised, early on.”

His theory is to take the points early. “You take your three, you take that scoreboard, you back yourself to get back down there again.” England might take the first two shots at goal, then go to the corner. On the field, he said, the call is always a feel.

But an early corner kick would not shock him. “That’s your statement of intent to 82,000 people, it’s huge. Suddenly the crowd goes even louder.”

England host New Zealand at Allianz Stadium, Twickenham, at 2.10pm GMT on Saturday 21 November. Youngs pointed to Maro Itoje. How England manage that will be interesting, he said. “That’s where someone like Maro’s experience is going to be critical, to be honest with you.”

READ MORE: Haskell: hurt All Blacks will come out guns blazing against England

How England Could Turn an All Blacks Upset Into a CrisisVideo · plays from YouTube
Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

England's Henry Pollock roaring in celebration at Twickenham against Australia
Next up

Ben Youngs: England’s Japan Test ‘like a glorified team run’

Youngs wants a fast start, backs the returning bench and says New Zealand are still the better team, but asks if England can pick the Wales scab.

England · 2 min read

More on England

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?