Skip to content

Haskell’s England yellow card stat: No 2 with 15, ninth with 14

Mike Tindall says nobody has made England defend for long this autumn. Two late cards cost them at Ellis Park. The All Blacks are next.

England hooker Jamie George, who said indiscipline let England down at Ellis Park
Photo: PA via The Irish News

England are the second-best side in the world with 15 men on the field, James Haskell says. One yellow card and they drop to ninth. Lose two and they are 11th.

The former England flanker cited the figure on The Good, The Bad & The Rugby, days before the All Blacks come to Twickenham. “If they keep players on the field for the entirety, they’re number two in the world,” he said.

Can England keep 15 men on the field against the All Blacks? Tell us in the comments.

Where does Haskell’s yellow card stat come from?

Haskell was talking on The Good, The Bad & The Rugby, the podcast he hosts with Alex Payne and Mike Tindall. The show credits its stats to Russ Petty and Oval Insights. It did not say how the ranking was worked out or over which games.

“Have they learned? Can they do it? Because the statistic is that if they lose a player, they go down to ninth. And if they lose two players, they go down to 11th in the world,” Haskell said.

On those numbers, a single card turns England into a mid-table team for 10 minutes.

READ MORE: England v New Zealand: preview, kick-off time and TV

England have not been put under pressure this autumn

Tindall’s worry is that nobody has made England defend for long. “What they haven’t really had to face this autumn as yet is any… considered period of pressure,” the former England centre said. Another voice on the panel added that pressure like that is “what has led to yellow cards in the past”.

The autumn so far backs him up. England beat Australia 45–22 at Allianz Stadium on 8 November, and the only yellow card went to Wallabies prop Angus Bell, for a hip-drop tackle.

Six days later they beat Japan 78–15. Japan lock Harry Hockings was sent off for a first-minute high tackle on Ellis Genge, his yellow upgraded to a 20-minute red. Hooker Luke Cowan-Dickie was England’s only card, a yellow in the 53rd minute for playing the ball from an offside position.

England finished two July Tests with 13 men

South Africa beat England 45–21 at Ellis Park on 4 July, the opening round of the Nations Championship.

Tommy Freeman was sent to the sin-bin in the 71st minute for a dangerous tackle. Guy Pepper followed a minute later for a late challenge, and England finished with 13 men. That made it 10 yellow cards and a red in England’s first six Tests of 2026, the Irish News reported.

“We have to take a lot more responsibility with regards to our discipline, which let us down,” hooker Jamie George said afterwards.

England have won four straight since, against Fiji, Argentina, Australia and Japan. Two weeks after Ellis Park, they were down to 13 again.

In Santiago del Estero, Jack van Poortvliet and Alex Coles were sent to the sin-bin, and Coles’s card came with a penalty try. Henry Pollock and Emmanuel Iyogun followed late on. England still held on to beat Argentina 31–24.

Will the All Blacks test England’s discipline at Twickenham?

They should. New Zealand arrive after losing 35–28 to Wales in Cardiff, a game Dan Biggar says left Richie Mo’unga “way off the pace”. John Kirwan has called Saturday’s Test “season defining” for the All Blacks. Haskell expects them to “come out… guns blazing”.

England v New Zealand kicks off at 2.10pm GMT on Saturday 21 November at Allianz Stadium, Twickenham. The South African panel on SuperSport has already called England “dangerous”.

Haskell wants to see England tested early. “It would be amazing in the first 10 minutes get a yellow card,” he said.

Our view: the stat says England’s ceiling is No 2 in the world. The first yellow card at Twickenham will tell us whether they can stay there for 80 minutes against the All Blacks.

READ MORE: Hip-drop tackle yellow card: ‘What’s he supposed to do?’ asks Schalk Burger

Rassie Erasmus Banned After “Match Fixing” CommentsVideo · plays from YouTube

Video: The Good, The Bad & The Rugby, “Rassie Erasmus Banned After ‘Match Fixing’ Comments”. The England discussion starts from 1:10:00.

Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?