Rassie Erasmus is banned, but Alex Payne thinks one of his complaints stands up. The host of The Good, The Bad & The Rugby said there is “validity to the points that he has raised”. Then he went through the clock on Maxime Lucu’s yellow card in Paris.
“What it’s definitely not is 10 minutes,” Payne said. Shane Horgan, the former Ireland wing beside him, agreed the timing “really shouldn’t happen”, but said there is “a huge difference between… going about it the right way and the potential damage that is… done”.
Did Rassie have a point about the Lucu sin-bin, or is the clock a sideshow? Tell us in the comments.
Rassie Erasmus said seven minutes, Payne says eight and a half
The France scrum-half was sent to the bin just before half-time in the 21-19 win over South Africa on 13 November, for a tackle on Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu. At Monday’s press conference in Dublin, Erasmus said Lucu’s card “was only seven minutes because the clock didn’t stop”, as reported by the Irish Times.
That press conference also had the “match fixing” question that got him banned for six matches.
Payne said Erasmus’s figure was low. “I think the official time is actually eight and a half minutes,” he said. “I think what has happened here is that the clock has run on during a formal review when it should have stopped.”
What the match clock shows on the Lucu yellow card
The Irish Times went through the footage. A TMO check just before half-time ruled out a Kurt-Lee Arendse try, and the paper says the clock kept running through it when it should have stopped.
By its count, Lucu came back about 68 seconds early. It puts his time off “closer to nine minutes”. Its verdict on the claim: “Erasmus is not right, but he’s not wrong either.”
So there are three numbers in play: seven from Erasmus, eight and a half from Payne, close to nine from the Irish Times. None of them is the 10 minutes the law asks for.
Horgan’s answer: ‘the dog in the street knows’
Payne put it to Horgan: “How do you reconcile the fact that he may have a point with the way that he’s gone about his work?”
“Because the dog in the street knows that rugby is an imperfect game and it’s… refereed imperfectly,” Horgan said. To him, “the idea that we can make the game perfect is… ludicrous.”
He still wants mistakes called out. “That doesn’t mean that we accept… inadequate refereeing or… blatant errors,” he said. Earlier in the show he said coaches can take complaints to World Rugby and referee assessors. “This is not the forum.”
Why a fair point still got Rassie Erasmus a six-match ban
Horgan draws the line at how Erasmus said it, and at what he gets out of saying it: “the advantage that’s gained by Rassie from… doing it in… the way that… he has done it.”
The panel found his comments suggested officials were biased or tried to change the result. At the centre of it was his question about a TMO who saw foul play and did nothing: “is that not match-fixing?” Horgan has harder words for him elsewhere on the show: his ‘Trumpian’ verdict is here.
The Irish Times gave him some ground on the knee-drop tackles too: “Erasmus has a case,” it said. But his claim that the TMO never stepped in was wrong. The TMO checked a Florian Verhaeghe tackle in the 39th minute.
It is still his third ban over comments on referees. Every Rassie Erasmus ban is listed here.
Erasmus misses Saturday’s Test against Ireland at the Aviva Stadium. SA Rugby has asked for a full hearing so he can “contextualise his comments”, and no date had been announced when we published.
READ MORE: Rassie Erasmus says a technicality will clear Sam Prendergast

Video: Alex Payne and Shane Horgan on The Good, The Bad & The Rugby, “Rassie Erasmus Banned After ‘Match Fixing’ Comments” (the Lucu sin-bin from 12:32).




Comments
No one has weighed in yet.
Be the first - what did you make of it?