Skip to content

Justin Marshall: Scotland v Wallabies ‘one of the worst games’

Marshall says both sides ruined his Sunday, and Jeremy Paul wants Tate McDermott in at nine for Cardiff.

Wallabies scrum-half Tate McDermott runs with the ball against Japan.
Photo: Getty Images

Justin Marshall says Scotland v Wallabies was “one of the worst games of rugby” he has watched this year. Scotland won 15–12 at Murrayfield. “Both of them are responsible for ruining my Sunday afternoon,” Marshall said.

Former Wallabies hooker Jeremy Paul, alongside him, wants a change at nine for the Wallabies’ next Test.

Should Tate McDermott start for the Wallabies against Wales? Tell us in the comments.

Why Marshall wishes he had gone to the pub

The former All Blacks halfback was speaking on The Good, The Bad & The Rugby: Australia & New Zealand. He had been looking forward to the game, and watched it instead of going to the pub.

“I could have been at the pub, JP. I could have been at the pub and I could have been having a few beers.”

He had hoped to see Australia turn things around at Murrayfield. Instead he got “that shambolic mess”.

Was kicking the problem in Scotland v Wallabies?

Paul brought up the kicking. Marshall agreed.

“That four-letter word that you just mentioned was the key to that game. Kick.”

He said both teams were coming off a loss, looked “afraid to play” and fell back on the boot.

The panel put the count at 55 kicks. “They were both so negative,” Marshall said.

READ MORE: Scotland v Australia: the stats from Murrayfield

Jeremy Paul wants Ryan Lonergan rested

Paul found positives. Australia let in only one try in each half, he said, and he called the defence “a tick”. He said the scrum “actually kept us in the game”.

His change is at scrum-half. “I’d like to see Lonergan actually have a rest. I’d like to see Tate McDermott come in.”

He said Ryan Lonergan has had “a breakout season, but his first season”, and “you can see the wear and tear on him now”.

He liked what the bench brought. When McDermott and Ben Donaldson came on, he said, the pair “actually sparked something”.

READ MORE: Harry Wilson says the Wallabies should have gone for goal against Scotland

Marshall backs McDermott and Daugunu to change the shape

Marshall agreed on Tate McDermott. “He is a lot more dangerous around the breakdowns,” he said. He added that McDermott nearly created a try in his eight or nine minutes off the bench.

He also wants Filipo Daugunu in midfield. “I’d like to see him get an opportunity maybe at centre.”

Host Andy Rowe argued the other way. He wants a settled nine and 10, such as Lonergan and Carter Gordon, given time together.

Marshall was not convinced. “Look, you could stick a nine and 10 out there for 10 games on the bounce and lose all 10.”

Wales v Australia kicks off at the Principality Stadium at 8.10pm GMT on Saturday 21 November. Wales come in off a 35–28 win over the All Blacks.

READ MORE: Jeremy Paul says the Wallabies ‘stupidly’ toured with ‘tired’ stars

Wales vs All Blacks: What Went Wrong For New Zealand?Video · plays from YouTube
Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Ewen McKenzie, the former Wallabies head coach and prop, in a Wallabies rain jacket.
Next up

Ewen McKenzie: Rugby ‘Might As Well Get Rid Of’ The Scrum

Former Wallabies head coach Ewen McKenzie has said rugby 'might as well get rid of' the scrum, arguing that free kicks have left it with no real contest.

Australia · 2 min read

More on Scotland

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?