Skip to content
News

Shane Horgan: Rassie Erasmus ban ‘a price he’s willing to pay’

The former Ireland wing on the 2021 Lions refereeing shift, why Erasmus keeps doing it, and his “bomb on a plane” reply to SA Rugby’s defence.

Rassie Erasmus in a water carrier's bib during the 2021 British & Irish Lions series in Cape Town, with a Lions player behind him
Photo: Photo via The Telegraph

Shane Horgan does not think a six-match ban will stop Rassie Erasmus. The former Ireland wing thinks the outbursts work. “One of the key elements why I think… Rassie does it is because it’s effective,” he said on The Good, The Bad & The Rugby. “It has been effective in the past and we saw that on the Lions tour.”

The ban, in his view, is just the bill. “Maybe it’s working for him. And part of the price is occasional, you know, six match bans and he’s… it’s a price he’s willing to pay.”

Is Horgan right that Rassie’s outbursts work, or is that unfair on the Springboks? Tell us in the comments.

Horgan says the 2021 Lions series turned after Erasmus’s video

The Lions won the first Test 22-17 in Cape Town. Erasmus then made an hour-long video picking apart Nic Berry’s refereeing, and it leaked. South Africa won the second Test 27-9 under Ben O’Keeffe and the third 19-16 under Mathieu Raynal to take the series.

Horgan was a Lions tourist himself in 2005. He saw a “change in the way the referees refereed the game… in the later tests… after Rassie’s outburst and that was to the advantage of… the Springboks.”

“Would Rassie do that again in order to secure a Lions series? Maybe he would,” he said. “And it does plant a seed and it does have, I think, you know, an impact on the way games are refereed.”

That is Horgan’s reading, not a finding, and the Springboks won those Tests on the field. Erasmus got a two-month ban over the video, the first of three Rassie Erasmus bans in five years.

Why Shane Horgan thinks this ban won’t change Rassie Erasmus

The third came on Tuesday. World Rugby banned Erasmus for six matches after he asked whether a TMO who saw foul play and did nothing was guilty of “match fixing”. It took effect immediately. SA Rugby has asked for a full misconduct hearing, and no date had been announced when we published.

Asked whether Erasmus lost control or planned it, Horgan said he was not sure. But he called him “smart enough and considered enough… he’s not saying it for no reason… he does use it to… ramp up pressure on officials.”

And he doubts the penalties have sunk in. “He’s never either got it or he’s never cared about it,” Horgan said, “or he’s thought the advantage that he gains from it is good enough… to keep on doing it.”

Does Erasmus have a point about the referees?

Partly, and the show said so. Host Alex Payne argued some complaints about the 21-19 defeat in Paris hold up, such as how long Maxime Lucu spent in the sin-bin. Horgan agreed the timing “really shouldn’t happen”.

His problem is the method. Coaches can take issues to World Rugby and to referee assessors, he said. “This is not the forum.”

Why ‘bomb on a plane’ is Horgan’s reply to SA Rugby

SA Rugby wants Erasmus “to contextualise his comments and assure the panel that it was not his intention to allege that any match official had acted with ulterior motives”, its statement said.

Horgan was not convinced. “It’s like saying bomb on a plane, isn’t it?” he said. “All the people are hearing is a bomb.”

He accepts Erasmus never called the officials match-fixers outright. “No, he set up a scenario and said that would be match fixing.” That, Horgan said, is what Erasmus will have to answer for at the hearing.

What does the ban mean for Ireland v South Africa?

Erasmus misses Saturday’s Test at the Aviva Stadium, the first of the six, and cannot enter the ground. At the same press conference he predicted a technicality would clear Sam Prendergast of his hip-drop citing. The panel has since dismissed the citing, so Prendergast is free to play.

Horgan doubts the ban changes much for the Springboks, who he expects to be “plenty angry” after the France loss. “They’re well able to deliver aggressive performance. I don’t think they were crying out for that.”

Ireland have a mixed recent record against South Africa in Dublin. Horgan also had harsher words for Erasmus on the same show: his “Trumpian” verdict is here.

Is Horgan reading too much into 2021, or is a six-match ban a price worth paying? Have your say in the comments.

Rassie Erasmus Banned After “Match Fixing” CommentsVideo · plays from YouTube

Video: Shane Horgan and Alex Payne on The Good, The Bad & The Rugby (Horgan on Erasmus and the Lions from 11:30).

Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?