Skip to content

South Africa player ratings v Ireland: Van Staden red costly

The Springboks made more metres than Ireland but lost 20-17 in Dublin, and finished with 14 men after Marco van Staden's red card.

A Springboks forward carries into Ireland's defence during the 20-17 defeat at the Aviva Stadium

Our South Africa player ratings v Ireland follow a 20-17 defeat at the Aviva Stadium on Saturday, in round 6 of the Nations Championship. South Africa made 318 metres to Ireland’s 296 and lost fewer turnovers, 10 to 16. They still lost, because Ireland scored three tries to two and the Springboks gave away 11 penalties.

Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu is the best of them at 7, with seven points and 50 metres, one short of Rob Baloucoune’s match-best 51. Replacement Marco van Staden gets the lowest mark after a red card with eight minutes left and three points in it. Tell us in the comments: who was South Africa’s best player in Dublin?

Where the Springboks lost it

Feinberg-Mngomezulu kicked a penalty in the 4th minute, but Rob Baloucoune scored twice for Ireland by the 18th. Morne van den Berg’s try, converted by Feinberg-Mngomezulu, levelled it at 10-10 in the 36th minute. Ronan Kelleher’s try put Ireland 17-10 up at half-time.

Sam Prendergast kicked a penalty in the 53rd minute. Malcolm Marx scored four minutes later and Feinberg-Mngomezulu converted, 20-17. Neither side scored again.

On 72 minutes Ireland’s Dan Sheehan was sin-binned and Van Staden was sent off, so the last eight minutes were 14 against 14.

Our Ireland v South Africa preview set out the numbers going in. This is how every Springboks player rated.

South Africa backs ratings v Ireland: Feinberg-Mngomezulu leads

15 Damian Willemse – 5
Made four tackles but carried only once before Canan Moodie replaced him after 26 minutes.

14 Kurt-Lee Arendse – 6
Made 34 metres from four carries, beat three defenders and won a lineout. One penalty conceded.

13 Jesse Kriel – 5.5
Beat three defenders, but his eight carries made only 13 metres. Six tackles.

12 Damian de Allende – 6
Made 13 tackles, joint second-most in the side, and was one of only two Springboks starters to make a line break. Replaced on 64 minutes.

11 Ethan Hooker – 6
Carried 10 times, more than any other Springboks player, for 34 metres. He also made nine tackles and won a turnover.

10 Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu – 7
South Africa’s best player. He scored seven points, two conversions from two and a penalty, and made 50 metres from six carries, more than any other Springboks player. He also made 11 tackles and won a lineout.

9 Morne van den Berg – 6.5
Scored the 35th-minute try that, once converted, made it 10-10. He made 73 passes, 13 kicks from hand, a line break and two offloads, and kept the Springboks moving all 80 minutes. One penalty conceded.

South Africa forwards ratings v Ireland: Mostert’s 15 tackles

1 Ox Nche – 5
Five tackles and two carries before the front row was changed on 47 minutes.

2 Malcolm Marx – 6.5
Scored the 57th-minute try that, once converted, cut it to 20-17. He made 21 metres from eight carries and 10 tackles before going off on 62 minutes, with one penalty against him.

3 Wilco Louw – 4.5
Made nine tackles but gave away two penalties in 47 minutes.

4 Eben Etzebeth – 6.5
Won five lineouts, more than anyone else on the pitch, and played the full 80. He made seven tackles and gave away one penalty.

5 Franco Mostert – 7
Made 15 tackles in 47 minutes, the most in the South Africa side. He also won three lineouts and a turnover.

6 Siya Kolisi – 6
Made 12 metres and five tackles in 47 minutes, and conceded a penalty.

7 Pieter-Steph du Toit – 6.5
Threw three offloads, the most in the match, and made 13 tackles in 53 minutes. One penalty conceded.

8 Cameron Hanekom – 6
Made 13 tackles, beat three defenders and won two turnovers, the most in the Springboks side.

South Africa bench ratings: Moodie’s two line breaks

16 Jan-Hendrik Wessels – 4.5 – Five carries for four metres and a penalty in 18 minutes.

17 Gerhard Steenekamp – 5.5 – Made seven tackles in 33 minutes.

18 Thomas du Toit – 6 – Made 23 metres from six carries and beat three defenders.

19 Lood de Jager – 5.5 – Carried eight times and won two lineouts.

20 Paul de Villiers – 6 – Made seven tackles and won a turnover.

21 Marco van Staden – 3.5 – Made 10 tackles in 25 minutes, but his red card on 72 minutes left his side a man down with the game still to win.

22 Grant Williams – 4.5 – Gave away a penalty in 16 minutes.

23 Canan Moodie – 6.5 – Made 42 metres and two line breaks after coming on in the 26th minute. One penalty conceded.

Feinberg-Mngomezulu or Etzebeth? See how the winners rated in our Ireland player ratings v South Africa.

South Africa player stats: Feinberg-Mngomezulu’s 50 metres lead

PlayerMinPtsCarriesMetresPassesOffloadsLine breaksTacklesTurnovers wonLineouts wonPens concededCardsRating
Damian Willemse2601000040005
Kurt-Lee Arendse80043421040116
Jesse Kriel80081320060005.5
Damian de Allende640914501130006
Ethan Hooker800103410091006
Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu807650710110107
Morne van den Berg805624732150016.5
Ox Nche4702110050005
Malcolm Marx625821100100016.5
Wilco Louw4703010090024.5
Eben Etzebeth8005210070516.5
Franco Mostert47033000151307
Siya Kolisi47041200050016
Pieter-Steph du Toit530614530130116.5
Cameron Hanekom740710000132006
Jan-Hendrik Wessels1805400020014.5
Gerhard Steenekamp3303000070005.5
Thomas du Toit33062310030006
Lood de Jager3308630050205.5
Paul de Villiers3303420071006
Marco van Staden2502511010000Red3.5
Grant Williams1601210010014.5
Canan Moodie54074200210116.5

READ ALSO: Ireland vs South Africa 20-17: Baloucoune Double Sinks the Boks

Giorgi Gulmagarashvili
Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Springboks head coach Rassie Erasmus in a Springboks cap
Next up

James Lowe on Rassie Erasmus ban: ‘A slip of the tongue maybe’

Lowe also explains why Ireland will 'circle the wagons', and why he won't be joining Rassie's watch-along.

Ireland · 2 min read

More on South Africa

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?