Skip to content

All Blacks player ratings v England: Jordie Barrett on top

New Zealand missed 35 tackles, lost 16 turnovers and made only three line breaks as England ran in five tries at Allianz Stadium.

All Blacks players with hands on heads during their defeat by England
Photo: The Independent

New Zealand lost 37-12 to England at Allianz Stadium on Saturday 21 November in round 6 of the Nations Championship. At 25 points it was the heaviest defeat the All Blacks have ever suffered against England, and England were worth every point.

These All Blacks player ratings make grim reading. New Zealand had 35% of the ball, made 313 metres to England’s 576 and were 19-0 down after 36 minutes. It was a worse night than the 35-28 defeat in Cardiff. Jordie Barrett‘s 7.5 is the highest mark in the side, and nobody else in black gets more than a 7. Tell us in the comments: too harsh, or fair after that?

Where it went wrong for New Zealand

England scored inside four minutes through Henry Slade and added tries from Jack van Poortvliet and Ben Earl before the All Blacks got going. Ethan de Groot’s try in the 38th minute made it 19-5 at half-time, but Ollie Chessum scored two minutes after the restart.

Beauden Barrett‘s converted try in the 51st minute cut it to 24-12, and that was as close as it got. Marcus Smith kicked two penalties and Seb Atkinson scored a fifth England try.

Defence is where it fell apart. New Zealand made 228 tackles, almost twice England’s 117, and still missed 35. They lost 16 turnovers, conceded 10 penalties to England’s seven, and won only eight of their 12 lineouts (66.7%). Earl alone carried 33 times; the All Blacks’ busiest carrier, Fabian Holland, managed 13.

All Blacks player ratings v England: the backs

15 Beauden Barrett – 7
New Zealand’s most dangerous player. He scored their second try, made 69 metres from seven carries (the most in the side) and two of the team’s three line breaks. Made two tackles and kicked four times before Richie Mo’unga replaced him at 67 minutes.

14 Will Jordan – 5
Jordan barely saw the ball: five carries for 12 metres before he went off at 52 minutes. Seven tackles and a turnover won.

13 Anton Lienert-Brown – 5
Both England centres scored on his watch. Eight tackles and 13 metres from four carries in 64 minutes.

12 Jordie Barrett – 7.5
New Zealand’s best player on a bad night, and it was all defence. He made 17 tackles, more than any other back on the pitch, and played the full 80. England’s 12, Seb Atkinson, carried 15 times for only 20 metres.

His own attack was thin: three carries for three metres and two penalties conceded. Bryn Hall has called him the best player in the world. Without the ball, he was the only All Black back who looked it.

11 Josh Moorby – 5
Six carries for 24 metres and five tackles in the full 80. The ball rarely reached the left wing.

10 Damian McKenzie – 5.5
Made 24 passes, 11 carries and eight tackles, and kicked one conversion. His 11 carries only made 14 metres and he conceded a penalty. New Zealand never got the platform for him to play off.

9 Cam Roigard – 6.5
One of the few All Blacks who threatened. He made 34 metres, the second-most in the team, a line break and beat three defenders. He also made 16 tackles, 50 passes and eight kicks before going off at 67 minutes.

Sititi, Lakai and Holland carry the forwards

1 Ethan de Groot – 6
Scored New Zealand’s first try just before half-time and made 11 tackles in 52 minutes. One penalty conceded.

2 Codie Taylor – 5.5
Sixteen tackles and a turnover won, but the lineout lost four of its 12 throws and he conceded a penalty.

3 Fletcher Newell – 5.5
The scrum won every feed it had. Around it, England won the collisions. Thirteen tackles in 64 minutes.

4 Scott Barrett – 6
The captain, Scott Barrett, made 17 tackles, won three lineouts and a turnover and made an offload. Two penalties conceded cost him.

5 Fabian Holland – 7
Carried 13 times, more than any other All Black, made 21 tackles and won three lineouts. Played all 80.

6 Tupou Vaa’i – 6
Seventeen tackles in 56 minutes, but four carries went nowhere: six metres.

7 Peter Lakai – 7
Won two turnovers, the most in the match, made 20 tackles and two offloads, and carried 11 times.

8 Wallace Sititi – 7
Sititi made 22 tackles, more than anyone on the pitch. He also carried 12 times for 30 metres, beat three defenders, won a turnover and a lineout, and made an offload. The best of the New Zealand forwards.

Replacements

16 Asafo Aumua – 5 – Five tackles and one carry in 24 minutes.

17 George Bower – 5.5 – Made 11 tackles in 28 minutes but conceded a penalty.

18 Pasilio Tosi – 5 – Two carries and two tackles in 16 minutes, and a penalty conceded.

19 Anton Segner – 5.5 – Made five tackles and won a lineout in 24 minutes.

20 Leicester Fainga’anuku – 5 – Three carries for nine metres in 16 minutes.

21 Cortez Ratima – 5 – Six passes and three tackles in 13 minutes, and a penalty conceded.

22 Richie Mo’unga – 6 – Three carries for 30 metres in 13 minutes. Nobody off the bench did more with the ball.

23 Rieko Ioane – 5.5 – Made 21 metres from three carries in 28 minutes but no tackles.

Every All Black’s numbers from Allianz Stadium

PlayerMinPtsCarriesMetresPassesOffloadsLine breaksTacklesTurnovers wonLineouts wonPens concededRating
Beauden Barrett67576980220007
Will Jordan52051240071005
Anton Lienert-Brown64041360080005
Jordie Barrett800331100170027.5
Josh Moorby80062420050005
Damian McKenzie8021114241080015.5
Cam Roigard6705345001160006.5
Ethan de Groot52531000110016
Codie Taylor56046200161015.5
Fletcher Newell64023100130005.5
Scott Barrett80042610171326
Fabian Holland8001317510210307
Tupou Vaa’i56046000170006
Peter Lakai800117720202007
Wallace Sititi8001230610221107
Asafo Aumua2401010050005
George Bower28000200110015.5
Pasilio Tosi1602210020015
Anton Segner2401710050105.5
Leicester Fainga’anuku1603910000005
Cortez Ratima1302360030015
Richie Mo’unga13033010020006
Rieko Ioane28032120000005.5

Ben Earl carried 33 times for 138 metres for England, more than any All Black managed in either category. See how he and the rest of the England side rated in our England player ratings v New Zealand, or get the full story in the England 37-12 New Zealand match report.

Giorgi Gulmagarashvili
Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Steve Hansen with All Blacks players wearing their bronze medals after the 2019 World Cup, the tournament where England beat his side in the semi-final.
Next up

Steve Hansen: All Blacks need ‘take mentality’ before England

Steve Hansen has said the young All Blacks beaten by Wales need a "take mentality", and used the 2019 defeat to England to show why. The former All Blacks head…

New Zealand · 3 min read

More on New Zealand

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?