Skip to content

England player ratings v New Zealand: A perfect 10 for Ben Earl

Earl carried 33 times for 138 metres, scored a try and topped England's tackle count as the All Blacks were beaten by 25 points at Allianz Stadium.

Ben Earl gives a thumbs up after scoring for England against New Zealand at Allianz Stadium, 21 November 2026
Photo: The Independent

Our England player ratings v New Zealand start with a 37-12 win at Allianz Stadium on Saturday 21 November, in round 6 of the Nations Championship. It is England’s biggest winning margin over the All Blacks. Five tries, 65% of the ball, 576 metres to 313 and 13 line breaks to 3. And a No 8 who carried 33 times.

Ben Earl was player of the match and gets a perfect 10. His 138 metres were 44% of everything the All Blacks gained all game, and he beat eight defenders when no New Zealander beat more than three. Every England starter gets at least 7.5, because nobody in white had a bad day. Tell us in the comments: do you agree with a perfect 10 for Earl, or is there a better shout?

How England took the All Blacks apart

Henry Slade scored in the fourth minute. Tries from Jack van Poortvliet and Earl made it 19-0 by the 36th. Ethan de Groot’s try just before half-time made it 19-5, but Ollie Chessum scored two minutes after the restart and the game never got close again.

Beauden Barrett pulled one back in the 51st minute. Replacement fly-half Marcus Smith answered with a penalty, Seb Atkinson scored the fifth try in the 62nd minute, and Smith’s late penalty made it 37-12.

England beat 35 defenders to New Zealand’s 15, won 10 of their 11 lineouts and lost only nine turnovers to the All Blacks’ 16. New Zealand had to make 228 tackles, almost twice as many as England’s 117, and missed another 35.

Earl’s 10 is the last of the starters below, at No 8. Every mark is backed by the official match data.

England player ratings: Earl’s 10 and the rest

15 George Furbank – 7.5
Tidy and dangerous from the back. Made 43 metres from eight carries, beat three defenders, made a line break and an offload, and kicked three times from hand. He only had one tackle to make all game, which says plenty about where the match was played.

14 Will Joseph – 8
England’s second-best metre-maker, with 63 from just seven carries, 9 metres a carry. He beat five defenders, the second-most in the side, broke the line once and made six tackles. Earl reckons Joseph looks just like his brother Jonathan.

13 Henry Slade – 8
Scored the opening try in the fourth minute and set the tone. He made 43 metres from six carries, a line break and seven passes, and made four tackles. A calm, classy game at outside centre.

12 Seb Atkinson – 8
Scored England’s fifth try to kill the game off in the 62nd minute. He took 15 carries, the second-most in the team, and made the hard yards in midfield even if they only added up to 20 metres. He also made eight tackles, 10 passes and a line break, and won a turnover.

11 Cadan Murley – 8
Made three line breaks, more than anyone else on the pitch. He added 52 metres from 10 carries, two offloads, four defenders beaten and six tackles in 67 minutes.

10 Fin Smith – 7.5
Ran the attack well with 21 passes, carried 11 times and made seven tackles before Marcus Smith replaced him at 55 minutes. England converted only two of the four tries scored while he was on, both by him, and that keeps him off an 8.

9 Jack van Poortvliet – 8.5
England’s conductor. He made 88 passes, 38 more than anyone else on the pitch. His 17 kicks from hand were one short of the whole New Zealand team’s total (18). He scored England’s second try, made six tackles and won a turnover.

1 Fin Baxter – 7.5
Made nine tackles in 52 minutes, the second-most in the England side, and carried nine times. He gave away one penalty, and the scrum didn’t lose a single feed while he was on.

2 Jamie George – 7.5
England’s lineout won 10 of 11 throws, and George made 28 metres from seven carries, good numbers for a hooker. Five tackles in 52 minutes.

3 Joe Heyes – 7.5
The scrum was rock solid at 100%, and he made six tackles. Two penalties conceded is the one mark against him.

4 Maro Itoje – 7.5
Played all 80 minutes, won two lineouts, carried seven times for 17 metres and made four tackles. A captain’s shift without much noise.

5 Alex Coles – 7.5
Made seven tackles and six carries and won a lineout. He came off at 52 minutes and came back for an 11-minute spell from the 68th, finishing with 63 minutes. One penalty conceded.

6 Ollie Chessum – 8.5
Ollie Chessum was England’s best forward after Earl. He scored two minutes after half-time to end any hope of a comeback. He won five lineouts, more than anyone else on the pitch, and added 40 metres from 10 carries, a line break, eight tackles and a turnover.

7 Ben Curry – 7.5
Made eight tackles in 52 minutes and won a lineout. Most of his work was at the bottom of rucks, which is where he likes it.

8 Ben Earl – 10
Player of the match, and as complete a game as you will see from a No 8. Ben Youngs said No 8 is where England lack a Kieran Read. This was the answer.

He carried 33 times, more than twice as many as anyone else in white and nearly a third of New Zealand’s entire total (109). Those carries made 138 metres, more than double the next-best England player and 44% of everything the All Blacks gained all game (313).

He beat eight defenders, the most on the pitch, and made two line breaks and an offload. His try in the 35th minute put England 17-0 up. Then he went and made 12 tackles, more than any other England player. He played all 80 minutes. He gave away one penalty. Nobody is docking a point for that.

Replacements

16 Luke Cowan-Dickie – 6.5 – Seven carries, an offload, three tackles and a turnover won in 28 minutes, though the carries only made five metres.

17 Ellis Genge – 7.5 – The biggest impact off the bench. He came on at 52 minutes and carried nine times for 41 metres, a huge return for a prop, with a line break and four tackles. He also won a lineout. One penalty conceded.

18 Will Stuart – 6 – One carry and one tackle in 28 minutes. The scrum stayed at 100%.

19 George Martin – 6.5 – Four carries for 10 metres and four tackles in 17 minutes across two spells.

20 Greg Fisilau – 7 – Busy from the moment he came on. Ten carries for 29 metres, three defenders beaten, a line break, an offload and a turnover won, against one penalty given away.

21 Henry Pollock – 6 – One carry and one pass in 13 minutes. The game was done by the time he arrived.

22 Ben Spencer – 6.5 – Made a line break, an offload and eight passes in 16 minutes.

23 Marcus Smith – 7 – Eight points in 24 minutes: a conversion and two penalties, the last of them to finish the game.

Earl’s 10 will start arguments. The All Blacks’ marks will start more.

England player stats: Earl’s 33 carries lead the list

PlayerMinPtsCarriesMetresPassesOffloadsLine breaksTacklesTurnovers wonLineouts wonPens concededRating
George Furbank80084391110007.5
Will Joseph80076300160008
Henry Slade80564370140008
Seb Atkinson8051520100181008
Cadan Murley670105242360008
Fin Smith5641117210070007.5
Jack van Poortvliet64575880061008.5
Fin Baxter5209710090017.5
Jamie George52072800050007.5
Joe Heyes5203200060027.5
Maro Itoje80071740040207.5
Alex Coles6306740070117.5
Ollie Chessum805104020181508.5
Ben Curry5202830080107.5
Ben Earl805331387121200110
Luke Cowan-Dickie2807521031006.5
Ellis Genge28094100140117.5
Will Stuart2801100010006
George Martin17041000040006.5
Greg Fisilau280102921131017
Henry Pollock1301010000006
Ben Spencer1601081120006.5
Marcus Smith2480030030007
Giorgi Gulmagarashvili
Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Steve Hansen with All Blacks players wearing their bronze medals after the 2019 World Cup, the tournament where England beat his side in the semi-final.
Next up

Steve Hansen: All Blacks need ‘take mentality’ before England

Steve Hansen has said the young All Blacks beaten by Wales need a "take mentality", and used the 2019 defeat to England to show why. The former All Blacks head…

New Zealand · 3 min read

More on England

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?