Skip to content

All Blacks gave England the ball ’39 times’, says Steven Bates

It started at the first lineout, Bates says. He would keep the locks, debate the hooker and slow the week down.

All Blacks captain Codie Taylor arrives at Twickenham before the England Test
Photo: Getty Images via MSN

Steven Bates says the All Blacks gave England the ball back 39 times in the 37-12 defeat at Twickenham. By his maths that is “pretty close to one every two minutes”. “We got absolutely beaten up,” he said on Sky Sport’s The Breakdown, before setting out what he would change for Saturday’s rematch. What would you change? Tell us in the comments.

READ MORE: All Blacks player ratings v England

Bates says it started to go wrong at the first lineout

Bates, introduced on the show as its “coaching brain”, went straight to the set piece. He pointed to the first lineout of the game.

“England did nothing for that. They didn’t compete. That is simply on us, okay? And that is our timing,” he said.

He said the losses at the set piece meant New Zealand had no platform to attack from. “We couldn’t get any gain line ball. We continuously were running backwards,” he said.

On top of that, Bates said, the All Blacks were beaten at the breakdown. Bryn Hall, the former Crusaders scrum-half, pointed to England’s 14 entries against New Zealand’s four.

He counts a giveaway every two minutes

He added up 10, 13 and 16 off the stats graphic. “Now that is 39 times we gave the ball back to England,” he said.

“Now I’m no mathematician but I think the game’s 80 minutes and I think 39 is pretty close to one every two minutes.”

Dave Rennie made a similar point after the game. The head coach said his side “turned over two to one to them”.

READ MORE: Dave Rennie’s full press conference after England

Bates would keep the All Blacks locks for England

Asked which one or two changes he would make for Saturday, Bates started with what he would keep.

“I don’t know who’s available 100%, but I’m keeping the locks the same,” he said.

Codie Taylor captained the side at Twickenham, with Asafo Aumua on the bench. Bates thinks that is worth a debate.

“The hooker would be an interesting conversation, but Codie is your captain,” he said. “We need some punch, and what Aumua does give us, he gives us some punch.”

His week would start slowly, with walkthroughs on defensive lineout roles early and high-tempo training saved for short bursts on Thursday and Friday.

He finished with a nod to Jeff Wilson, known on the show as “Goldie”. “So, to use your words, Goldie, when we go back out there next weekend, we’re ready to beat some people up.”

Wilson wants Rieko Ioane on the field

Wilson wants Rieko Ioane involved, “maybe at 13, maybe on the wing”. He floated Anton Segner for the No 6 jersey if Tupou Vaa’i is not available.

Wilson said the bench had to make a difference again. “A bench has to be the impactful bench we’ve seen for all of the season,” he said.

Hall put rest first. “I think it’s an important week to just recover,” he said.

New Zealand face England again at Twickenham on Saturday 28 November, kick-off 4.40pm UK time. Would you start Aumua ahead of the captain, or keep the same pack?

READ MORE: Rennie on the rematch: ‘We need to work out why’

A Closer Look at the All Blacks Defeat to England | The Breakdown
A Closer Look at the All Blacks Defeat to England | The BreakdownVideo · plays from YouTube
Giorgi Gulmagarashvili
Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Anton Lienert-Brown dives over for the All Blacks
Next up

Anton Lienert-Brown: ‘Very little or none of our game got going’

The All Blacks centre says the plan from the huddle never turned into action, and explains why Twickenham punishes teams who play in the wrong areas.

New Zealand · 2 min read

More on New Zealand

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?