Skip to content

Sir Graham Henry: All Blacks have ‘run out of petrol’

The 2011 World Cup-winning coach, now a selector, says 13 Tests and a Springboks series have left the All Blacks with nothing in the tank, and that sacking Rennie is not the answer.

Sir Graham Henry at an All Blacks training session
Photo: Imago

Sir Graham Henry says the All Blacks are spent. The 2011 World Cup-winning coach is now a selector in Dave Rennie’s group. He told Newstalk ZB’s Mike Hosking that the players have “run out of petrol” after the record 37-12 defeat to England.

“It’s the end of the season and we’re buggered,” he said, as reported by the NZ Herald.

Asked whether Rennie should be sacked, Henry answered: “No, no, no, no.” Is he right that this is fatigue, or is that too easy an answer? Tell us in the comments.

What did Sir Graham Henry say about the All Blacks?

That the effort is there and the legs are not. “They’ve just got no gas in the tank, which is unfortunate, but that’s the way it is,” he told Hosking.

Henry has been around the squad all year and called them “a great bunch of guys”. His explanation was simple: too much rugby. In his words, “they’re human and they’ve just run out of gas.”

He is not the only one saying it. Rennie was asked about fatigue straight after Twickenham. On Monday, NZ Rugby chief executive Steve Lancaster said the union will look at whether the long year was a factor.

How many Tests have the All Blacks played in 2026?

By Henry’s count, Saturday’s rematch will be their 13th Test of the year. They had played 12 before that, he said, plus four provincial games on a big tour of South Africa.

He compared it with the way northern hemisphere sides look in New Zealand in July. They struggle at the end of their season, he said, “and we struggle [in Europe] in November, because it’s the end of the season and we’re buggered.”

The four-Test Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry series is the centre of his case. “It’s a massive challenge for the players and they’ve hit the wall – just like South Africa hit the wall,” he said. The Springboks have lost twice this month, to France in Paris and to Ireland in Dublin.

Why does Henry call the All Blacks a ‘golden goose’?

Because they pay for everyone else. Henry said the All Blacks are “the only team that makes money for the rest of the teams in black”. He added that this year’s schedule is “the biggest itinerary they’ve ever had”.

“You’ve got to be careful you don’t kill the golden goose,” he warned.

Should Dave Rennie be sacked?

Not according to Henry. “God, we just need to be realistic and understand what is going on instead of talking a lot of rubbish half the time,” he told Hosking.

NZ Rugby agrees. Lancaster gave Rennie the union’s “full support” on Monday, and Rennie has backed his own staff since the loss.

The two sides meet again on Saturday 28 November in the Nations Championship third-place play-off at Allianz Stadium. Kick-off is 4.40pm UK time, 5.40am on Sunday in New Zealand.

Our view: Henry is half right

Tired legs are real, and 13 Tests with a four-match Springboks series in the middle is a brutal year. Henry is also right that sacking a coach before the last game of it would be noise.

But fatigue explains a fade in the last 20 minutes. It explains less when the damage came at the lineout and in the defensive line, which is exactly where Rennie’s assistants are under the spotlight. If the All Blacks are only tired, Saturday should look closer. If it does not, that answer runs out of petrol too.

READ MORE: England vs New Zealand 37-12: Record win, report and full stats

Giorgi Gulmagarashvili
Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

Beauden Barrett of the All Blacks lines up a kick
Next up

Beauden Barrett: All Blacks ‘a tight bunch’ after 37-12 loss

Dave Rennie says "I'm a big part of that" after a fifth Test defeat of 2026 put the All Blacks alongside the 1949 and 1998 sides.

New Zealand · 2 min read

More on New Zealand

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?