Skip to content

Jeff Wilson: ‘Clearly Super Rugby is not working’

The former All Blacks wing brought his own numbers to The Breakdown. Steven Bates and Bryn Hall backed him up.

Crusaders players link arms in a line before a Super Rugby Pacific match
Photo: Ultimate Rugby

Jeff Wilson says his own research shows Super Rugby is failing the All Blacks, with New Zealand‘s win rate against the north down from 90% to 67%. “Clearly Super Rugby is not working. It’s not,” the former All Blacks wing said on Sky Sport’s The Breakdown. Is he right? Tell us in the comments.

READ MORE: England 37-12 New Zealand: the match report

Wilson’s numbers show Super Rugby sides slipping since 2020

Wilson spoke the morning after England beat New Zealand 37-12 at Twickenham, a week on from the 35-28 loss to Wales in Cardiff. The host had just told viewers the All Blacks were fifth in the world rankings.

He said he had looked at how New Zealand have fared against northern hemisphere sides since South Africa left Super Rugby.

“For that ten-year period, 10 to 19, 90% record against the northern hemisphere. It’s now 67% in the last five years,” he said.

He gave the Wallabies’ numbers too. “Over that ten-year period, 58%, and now it’s at 34%, just one in three games.”

South Africa’s four franchises left Super Rugby after 2020 and now play in the United Rugby Championship and the Champions Cup.

He wants NZR and the provincial unions to look hard at themselves

Wilson went after the people who run the game.

“Clearly Super Rugby is not working. It’s not, and I think New Zealand Rugby right now and I think the provincial unions need to take a hard look at themselves,” he said.

He said Australia were no longer pushing New Zealand every year, and that the gap shows in the Bledisloe Cup. “They’re not a legitimate opposition for us on a yearly basis,” he said.

“If we don’t strengthen Super Rugby, if it isn’t more competitive on a consistent basis, then we’re not going to see the players develop.”

READ MORE: Jamie Wall says David Kirk now has to act

Bates says NPC coaches get just 10 days

Fellow panellist Steven Bates answered as a coach. He said the NPC, New Zealand’s provincial competition, cannot develop players on its current build-up.

“If you want NPC to be a truly development competition, don’t give us 10 days to prepare for it,” he said.

He said the build-up is meant to be three weeks, but by the time players return from Super Rugby, coaches have their full squad for about 10 days.

He said the northern clubs are tested by different styles every week in the Champions Cup. New Zealand teams, he said, mostly face sides who play the way they do.

Hall says the edge went with South Africa

Bryn Hall, a former Crusaders scrum-half, said South African sides used to give New Zealand teams “a different look”, and the competition was at its best then.

“We would arguably say that our competition was the best in the world,” he said. “…Now the competitiveness just isn’t there.”

The All Blacks face England again at Twickenham on Saturday 28 November, kick-off 4.40pm UK time. Who should fix Super Rugby first: NZR or the unions? Tell us in the comments.

READ MORE: Dave Rennie backs his All Blacks staff

A Closer Look at the All Blacks Defeat to England | The Breakdown
A Closer Look at the All Blacks Defeat to England | The BreakdownVideo · plays from YouTube
Giorgi Gulmagarashvili
Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

All Blacks captain Codie Taylor arrives at Twickenham before the England Test
Next up

All Blacks gave England the ball ’39 times’, says Steven Bates

It started at the first lineout, Bates says. He would keep the locks, debate the hooker and slow the week down.

New Zealand · 2 min read

More on Super Rugby

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?