James Haskell won 77 caps for England and played a Super Rugby season for the Highlanders in Dunedin. So when Alex Payne asked him on The Good, The Bad & The Rugby where his swapped All Blacks shirts had ended up, the answer surprised the studio. “A lot of Kiwis wouldn’t swap,” Haskell said.
“Stay humble,” he said of their attitude. “They wouldn’t swap…” Then he explained why the All Blacks are still, for him, “the most important scalp ever”.
Should players swap shirts after a Test, or are the All Blacks right to keep theirs? Tell us in the comments.
Why a win over New Zealand sits ‘on a huge pedestal’
Haskell was alongside Mike Tindall, a 2003 World Cup winner, and admitted the two of them see these games differently. For Haskell, “beating New Zealand for me is on a huge pedestal”.
“I did it once in X amount of encounters, it wasn’t a thing you ever did,” he said.
That once was 1 December 2012 at Twickenham. Haskell came off the bench as England won 38-21, only their seventh win over the All Blacks in 35 Tests. He lost to them on England’s tours of New Zealand in 2008 and 2014. Plenty of Wales greats never beat the All Blacks at all.
Is the All Blacks aura still there after Cardiff?
Haskell says the fear has stayed with him. His “own trauma”, he said, “is that you don’t beat New Zealand”.
He called that weird, because he thinks that mystique has already been broken. Cardiff proved it. Wales beat New Zealand 35-28 on Saturday 14 November, their first win over them since 1953. Dan Biggar called it the biggest shock since Japan beat South Africa.
It has not changed how he ranks them. “I think for me as a scalp, they are the most important scalp ever,” he said.
What makes New Zealand so hard to beat?
He still remembers how close 2012 came to slipping away. “Manu was sensational,” he said of Manu Tuilagi. England led 15-0 before Julian Savea and Kieran Read scored two tries in three minutes. Brad Barritt, Chris Ashton and Tuilagi then scored three in eight minutes to put the game away.
For Haskell, the threat starts with depth. “When you’re facing a country whose national sport is rugby, they get the cream of the crop,” he said. He pointed to their pace and handling, and to their support play: “A guy breaks through, there’s always someone on their shoulder because that’s the way they play.”
England’s record has improved, but not as much as Haskell thinks
Haskell believes England have beaten New Zealand more often in the past ten years than in all the years before. He added that he wasn’t sure, and the numbers don’t quite back him.
Since 2016, England have two wins: the 2019 World Cup semi-final, 19-7 in Yokohama, and 33-19 at Allianz Stadium last November. They also drew 25-25 in 2022. Before 2016 they had seven wins. All Blacks attack coach Mike Blair had a sharp answer this week when asked about his own Twickenham record.
James Haskell backs England to win 25-19 on Saturday
England host New Zealand at Allianz Stadium on Saturday 21 November. Asked for a quick prediction, Haskell went for an England win, 25-19.
He has also warned that discipline could decide it. Read his yellow card stat on England, and our England v New Zealand preview for the build-up.
A win would give a new group of England players the scalp Haskell rates above all others. Whether any All Blacks swap shirts with them afterwards is another question.
READ MORE: John Kirwan: Twickenham is ‘season defining’ for the All Blacks

Video: The Good, The Bad & The Rugby, “Rassie Erasmus Banned After ‘Match Fixing’ Comments” (the shirt-swap chat starts at 1:11:01).




Comments
No one has weighed in yet.
Be the first - what did you make of it?