Skip to content

Dave Rennie Backs All Blacks Staff: ‘We’ve Got A Great Group’

The Herald has Neil Barnes and Tana Umaga in the spotlight after the 37-12 loss. Rennie says his view of his staff has not changed. Here is the case for and against.

All Blacks head coach Dave Rennie before a Test
Photo: Getty Images via RugbyPass

Dave Rennie has refused to turn on his staff after the All Blacks’ 37-12 record defeat to England at Twickenham, even as the NZ Herald puts forwards coach Neil Barnes and defence coach Tana Umaga under the spotlight.

“Staffing-wise, we’ve got a great group,” Rennie said at his post-match press conference. “Tonight’s result is disappointing. It hasn’t changed my view on the quality of the people.”

Should Barnes and Umaga keep their jobs if England win again next Saturday? Tell us in the comments.

What did Dave Rennie say about his staff?

The question was broad. Rennie was asked whether a loss this heavy made him think about the preparation and whether he had “the right mix in personnel and preparation”. The question, as published by allblacks.com, did not name Barnes or Umaga, and nor did Rennie.

He backed his players and his staff. “I’ve got no doubt about the quality of the people that we have,” he said, according to allblacks.com. “It was a poor night, but from a playing perspective we’ve got excellent men.”

Elsewhere in the same allblacks.com report, he kept the blame for himself. “As head coach, you’re responsible for all the results,” he said, adding that he is “a big part of that”.

Why are Barnes and Umaga in the spotlight?

Because their parts of the game broke down. The Herald’s Liam Napier wrote that the spotlight is on Barnes and Umaga “as their respective areas falter”.

The numbers from our England vs New Zealand 37-12 match report back that up:

Lineout (Barnes): the All Blacks won only eight of their 12 throws, and Rennie called the scrum “messy”.

Defence (Umaga): 35 missed tackles and 13 line breaks conceded against three made.

Rennie admitted the plan to come up with line speed and stay connected failed “two or three times in that first half, and they hurt us”.

Our view: keep them for the rematch, then review

Sacking an assistant with seven days to go before a rematch with the same opponent would be panic, and Rennie’s answer suggests he has no plans to.

But Saturday is now an audition. England exposed the lineout and the defensive line in one night, and they will come at the same areas again. If the lineout still wobbles and the line still splits on Saturday, “a great group” will be hard to defend once the season is over.

The scrutiny is not going away. Napier called it “easily the most damaging” defeat of Rennie’s tenure, as quoted by 1News, and 1News headlined its round-up of the world reaction “Totally trashed”.

How bad was the defeat?

It was the third-largest defeat in All Blacks history and their record loss to England, according to the Herald. It was also Rennie’s fifth loss in his first year, the worst debut-year record since 1998, 1News reports. A sixth next week would equal 1949.

For individual marks, see our All Blacks player ratings v England. A week earlier Rennie said his side had let the country down in Cardiff. He said this was “a way worse performance”.

The rematch is on Saturday 28 November at 16:40 GMT, again at Twickenham.

READ MORE: Dave Rennie On England Loss: “I’m A Big Part Of That”

Giorgi Gulmagarashvili
Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

The All Blacks perform the haka before England v New Zealand at Allianz Stadium
Next up

All Blacks v England Again: Can Rennie Fix It In 7 Days?

Line speed, lineouts and turnovers: Dave Rennie has a week to fix the problems England exposed before the All Blacks face them again on finals weekend.

New Zealand · 2 min read

More on New Zealand

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?