James Haskell says that if England beat the All Blacks at Twickenham on Saturday, “everyone needs to shut the [—] up about Steve Borthwick”.
The former England flanker had a message for the Borthwick critics too. “All the armchair pundits need to dry their eyes and move on,” he said on The Good, The Bad & The Rugby on 18 November.
Would one win over the All Blacks end the Borthwick debate for you? Tell us in the comments.
Haskell was talking to host Alex Payne and former England centre Mike Tindall. England host New Zealand at Allianz Stadium, Twickenham on Saturday 21 November, kick-off 2.10pm GMT.
The All Blacks arrive after a 35-28 defeat by Wales in Cardiff, a loss John Kirwan puts down to a “mental lapse”.
Why would one win silence the Borthwick critics?
Haskell expects a very different New Zealand from the side beaten in Cardiff. Beating them, he said, would be “a really, really, really important moment”.
“I think if we do this, I think it’s now time to cheer the [—] up, stop whinging, get on board with him, go into the World Cup and get on with it,” he said.
A defeat, he accepted, would bring the questions back, depending on how England lost.
“Let’s get behind our team and go into a World Cup full of energy, full of positivity,” he added. “Stop with the narrative.”
Tindall was with him. “I 100% agree,” he said. He had thought since the start of the series that England had “a chance of knocking over this New Zealand team”.
READ MORE: SuperSport’s Verdict panel call England ‘on the rise’ and ‘dangerous’
Is Borthwick really the coach under most pressure?
Haskell thinks so. Nobody, he said, was suggesting Fabien Galthié should lose his job with France, and nobody was calling for Andy Farrell’s in Ireland.
“The person that’s been under the most pressure is, I think, Steve Borthwick,” he said.
The record backs him up. England had lost five of their eight Tests in 2026 before they beat Australia 45-22 on 8 November. That week, captain Maro Itoje denied newspaper reports of a “toxic environment” in camp.
Across those two Nations Championship wins, Borthwick’s side have scored 123 points, including a 13-try, 78-15 win over Japan.
Why Haskell calls it ‘the game of the tournament’
He did not play Saturday down. “This is the game of the tournament for me,” Haskell said.
He called it “the biggest moment for any side in this tournament”, because if England “get it right, then it changes the whole spectrum going to the World Cup”.
There is a trophy in it, too. England are chasing a place in the Nations Championship final at Twickenham at the end of the month.
Do the numbers favour England or New Zealand?
The scoreboard says it will be close. Payne told the panel that the 12 meetings since England’s famous win in 2012 have averaged “22 New Zealand, England 20”.
“So it’s always really tight,” he said.
England won the most recent of them, 33-19 at Twickenham in November 2025. Haskell said he had already tipped England to win 25-20, and Tindall had gone for 27-25.
So two of the three in the studio backed England. Lose on Saturday, and the armchair pundits Haskell wants silenced will have the last word going into a World Cup year.
READ MORE: England v New Zealand: Eddie Jones says beaten All Blacks are ‘violent’

Video: The Good, The Bad & The Rugby, 18 November 2026. The England v New Zealand discussion starts at 1:06:00.




Comments
No one has weighed in yet.
Be the first - what did you make of it?