Skip to content

Jamie Wall says David Kirk must act after England loss

Why Jamie Wall thinks the All Blacks assistant coaches are now exposed.

New Zealand Rugby chair David Kirk speaks to the media
Photo: NZ Herald

Days before Twickenham, New Zealand Rugby chair David Kirk set his own test, according to Jamie Wall. Now Wall says the All Blacks have left him nowhere to hide. “I don’t think they’ve given him any room to do anything other than take some sort of action over this,” the DSPN reporter told the Aotearoa Rugby Pod. What should Kirk do? Tell us in the comments.

READ MORE: Rennie backs his All Blacks staff

Wall says David Kirk set the bar at the manner

Wall said DSPN sat down with Kirk a few days before England beat New Zealand 37-12.

Kirk’s case for replacing Scott Robertson as head coach, Wall said, was that the team was not on the right trajectory. So DSPN asked what the trajectory looked like now.

According to Wall, Kirk said NZR was very happy with the build-up to the World Cup, despite the loss to Wales. Then they asked what would happen if New Zealand lost again.

“Kirk told us, he said this weekend wasn’t so much about the win or the loss. It was how they won or lost,” Wall said.

On Saturday they lost by 25 points, and Wall says the manner was the worst part.

Wall says this fixture finished Robertson last year

Wall linked it to 12 months ago. In his account, the same tour game was where things turned for Robertson.

“This was the game that did it for Scott Robertson. This is where it all started to come out,” he said. He said the relationship with the touring media broke down then, and what he called the player review story began to emerge.

He also put the season in context. Five defeats, he said, equals the most in a season if you go back to 1998. He admitted the schedules then were very different.

Do the assistants pay the price?

When the host said Dave Rennie was probably safe, Wall agreed. He called a coach change in a World Cup year “unprecedented” for a contender.

“I agree with you, but I think there’s going to be some changes to the assistants,” he said.

He pointed to 2022, when the series loss to Ireland cost half the assistant coaching staff their jobs. He said that was not as bad as what is happening now.

The catch, in his view, is who replaces them. He said there are few obvious candidates in Super Rugby or around the world.

“Do you have a list of names? Because I don’t,” Wall told the host.

Rennie has already backed his coaching group in public since the defeat.

His verdict on how the squad is being managed was short. “Something obviously has to change because what they’re doing right now isn’t bloody working,” he said.

The All Blacks play England again at Twickenham on Saturday 28 November (4.40pm UK). Wall says they will go in as underdogs, and Kirk’s test still applies.

READ MORE: All Blacks v England rematch: Rennie has seven days

REACTION: All Blacks' Twickenham nightmare
REACTION: All Blacks' Twickenham nightmareVideo · plays from YouTube
Giorgi Gulmagarashvili
Written by

Former Georgian U20 rugby player turned rugby journalist — founder of WeTalkRugby and the GG Rugby YouTube channel.

All Blacks players walk off dejected after a Test defeat
Next up

Jamie Wall: ‘This is probably the worst All Black loss ever’

The DSPN reporter explains why England 37-12 hurts more than last year’s defeat to South Africa.

New Zealand · 2 min read

More on New Zealand

Our favourite stories

Latest

The daily rugby email

Rugby news on your teams, in one email every morning.

I want the free WeTalkRugby daily email and I understand I can unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Comments

No one has weighed in yet.

Be the first - what did you make of it?